Moon Soul Graduate School of Future Strategy, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Daejeon, Korea.
Ministry of Strategy and Finance, Sejong Government Complex, Sejong, Korea.
PLoS One. 2019 Jan 23;14(1):e0209844. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0209844. eCollection 2019.
Complexity in nature has been broadly found not only in physical and biological systems but also in social and economic systems. Although many studies have examined complex systems and helped us understand real-world complexity, the investigation to the legal complexity has not been thoroughly investigated. Here we introduce a novel approach to studying complex legal systems using complex network approaches. On the basis of the bipartite relations among Constitution articles and Court decisions, we built a complex legal network and found the system shows the heterogeneous structure as generally observed in many complex social systems. By treating legal networks as unique political regimes, we examine whether structural properties of the systems have been influenced as the society changes, or not. On one hand, there is a core structure in all legal networks regardless of any social circumstances. On the other hand, with relative comparison among different regimes' networks, we could identify characteristic structural properties that reveal their identity. Our analysis would contribute to provide a better understanding of legal complexity and practical guidelines for use in various legal and social applications.
自然界的复杂性不仅存在于物理和生物系统中,也存在于社会和经济系统中。尽管许多研究已经考察了复杂系统并帮助我们理解了现实世界的复杂性,但对法律复杂性的研究还没有得到彻底的研究。在这里,我们介绍了一种使用复杂网络方法研究复杂法律系统的新方法。基于宪法条款和法院判决之间的二分关系,我们构建了一个复杂的法律网络,并发现该系统表现出与许多复杂社会系统中普遍观察到的异质结构。通过将法律网络视为独特的政治制度,我们研究了随着社会的变化,系统的结构特性是否受到了影响。一方面,无论社会环境如何,所有法律网络都存在核心结构。另一方面,通过对不同制度网络的相对比较,我们可以确定揭示其身份的特征结构属性。我们的分析将有助于更好地理解法律复杂性,并为各种法律和社会应用提供实用指南。