Broulikova Hana M, Sladek Vaclav, Arltova Marketa, Cerny Jakub
University of Economics, Prague. Department of Statistics and Probability, University of Economics; W. Churchill Sq. 1938/4, 130 67 Prague, Czech Republic,
J Ment Health Policy Econ. 2018 Dec 1;21(4):147-161.
In Czechia, only about a quarter of people suffering from the Alzheimer's disease (AD) receive (usually belated) treatment. Because of their more rapid cognitive decline, untreated patients require extensive assistance with basic daily activities earlier than those receiving treatment. This assistance provided at home and nursing homes represents a substantial economic burden.
To calculate lifetime costs of care per AD patient and to evaluate potential care savings from early treatment.
We use Monte Carlo simulation to model lifetime societal costs of care per patient under two different scenarios. In the first one, a cohort of 100,000 homogeneous patients receives usual care under which the majority of patients are undiagnosed or diagnosed late. The second scenario models a hypothetical situation in which an identical cohort of patients starts receiving treatment early after the disease onset. Data on the rates of cognitive decline for treated and untreated patients, and survival probability for AD patients are derived from foreign clinical studies. Information on costs and population characteristics is compiled on the basis of published Czech research and databases.
Early treatment of AD decreases social lifetime costs of care. This result holds true regardless of gender, age at which the disease is contracted, or whether the patient lives at home or uses a social residential service. The potential savings amount up to Euro 26,800 (23,500) per woman (man), being negatively correlated with the age at which the disease onsets as well as the delay between the onset and treatment initiation DISCUSSION: The results suggest that early treatment of AD would decrease costs of care in Czechia. The main limitation of the simulation arises from the fact that missing domestic information was substituted by input from foreign clinical trials or simplifying assumptions. Because of insufficient data, we do not model hospitalization risk; on the other hand, introduction of this risk into our model would likely increase the savings from early treatment.
Makers of AD policies ought to appreciate the trade-off between costs of daily assistance in untreated patients and health care costs in treated patients, notwithstanding that the costs of assistance are largely born by households rather than public budgets. Our results show that the savings on costs of assistance brought about by early treatment would exceed the additional costs of treatment.
A number of missing or insufficient data about the Czech Alzheimer's population were identified. In addition, to determine the total societal cost-effect of early treatment, further research ought to evaluate the related increase in detection costs. Finally, it should also assess cost-effectiveness of early treatment by considering its impact on patients' utility.
在捷克,只有约四分之一的阿尔茨海默病(AD)患者接受(通常较晚)治疗。由于认知能力下降更快,未接受治疗的患者比接受治疗的患者更早需要大量基本日常生活协助。在家中和养老院提供的这种协助带来了巨大的经济负担。
计算每位AD患者的终身护理成本,并评估早期治疗可能节省的护理费用。
我们使用蒙特卡罗模拟对两种不同情况下每位患者的终身社会护理成本进行建模。第一种情况是,一组10万名同质患者接受常规护理,其中大多数患者未被诊断或诊断较晚。第二种情况模拟了一种假设情况,即相同的一组患者在疾病发作后尽早开始接受治疗。治疗和未治疗患者的认知衰退率以及AD患者的生存概率数据来自国外临床研究。成本和人口特征信息是根据已发表的捷克研究和数据库汇编的。
AD的早期治疗降低了社会终身护理成本。无论性别、患病年龄,或者患者是在家居住还是使用社会居住服务,这一结果均成立。每位女性(男性)潜在节省金额高达26,800欧元(23,500欧元),与疾病发作年龄以及发作与开始治疗之间的延迟呈负相关。
结果表明,AD的早期治疗将降低捷克的护理成本。模拟的主要局限性在于,缺失的国内信息由国外临床试验的输入或简化假设替代。由于数据不足,我们没有对住院风险进行建模;另一方面,将这种风险纳入我们的模型可能会增加早期治疗的节省金额。
AD政策制定者应该认识到未治疗患者的日常协助成本与治疗患者的医疗保健成本之间的权衡,尽管协助成本在很大程度上由家庭而非公共预算承担。我们的结果表明,早期治疗带来的协助成本节省将超过额外的治疗成本。
确定了一些关于捷克AD人群的缺失或不足数据。此外,为了确定早期治疗的总体社会成本效益,进一步的研究应该评估相关的检测成本增加。最后,还应该通过考虑其对患者效用的影响来评估早期治疗的成本效益。