Williams Karen A, Lawson Robin M, Perurena Osvaldo H, Coppin John D
Central Texas Veterans Health Care System, Medical Service, 1901 Veterans Memorial Drive, Temple, TX.
University of Alabama, Capstone College of Nursing, 650 University Blvd, E, Tuscaloosa, AL.
Mil Med. 2019 Jul 1;184(7-8):e207-e211. doi: 10.1093/milmed/usy405.
The rate of chronic migraine (CM) has been shown to be 20% or greater in the post 9/11 combat veteran population with a history of traumatic brain injury, while the rate is much lower at 3-5% in the general population. Studies have shown that medications such as oral topiramate or intramuscular injections of onabotulinum toxin A (Botox) have been used for CM prevention, and occipital blocks have been shown to be helpful in treating occipital neuralgia and short-term relief of CM. However, there are no known studies that have specifically evaluated the use of Botox and occipital blocks for reducing headache frequency in the US veteran population. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of using occipital blocks and Botox as dual therapy for reducing headache frequency in post 9/11 combat veterans with CM, occipital neuralgia, and a history of TBI or neck trauma.
Following Institutional Review Board approval, a retrospective chart review was completed on post 9/11 combat veterans treated in a headache clinic located at the Central Texas Veteran Health Care System. The electronic medical record was used to retrieve the charts of post 9/11 combat veterans who (1) had a confirmed deployment-related history of TBI or neck trauma; (2) were diagnosed with CM and occipital neuralgia; and (3) were treated in the headache clinic between January 1, 2014 and December 31, 2015 with the administration of occipital blocks and Botox within the first six months. Of 282 charts that were reviewed, a total of 30 (N = 30) veterans fit the criteria. The mean number of self-reported headache days per month (28 days) for the month prior to starting treatment was compared to the number of headache days per month (28 days) 6 months after initiation of therapy.
Results revealed that the mean number of headache days in the month prior to treatment was 24.1 (22.0, 25.7). The mean number of headache days in the month post-treatment (6 months after the initiation of dual therapy with occipital blocks and Botox) was 12.9 (9.7, 16.4). The mean difference in the number of headache days from pre- to post-treatment (pre-treatment minus post-treatment) was 11.2 (8.2, 14.2).
This study evaluated the effectiveness of using occipital blocks and Botox as dual therapy for reducing headache frequency for post 9/11 combat veterans with CM, occipital neuralgia, and a history of TBI or neck trauma. Results revealed a statistically significant reduction in the number of headache days per month after the dual therapy. There were multiple limitations to the study to include a small sample size, lack of a control group, self-reported headaches for only 1 month pre-and post-treatment, and no control for other interventions or events which may have influenced the outcome. There is a strong need for randomized, double blinded, placebo- controlled studies involving dual therapy in this population. This study, though small, may be helpful in stimulating additional studies and treatments in this veteran population.
在有创伤性脑损伤病史的9·11事件后的退伍军人中,慢性偏头痛(CM)的发生率已被证明达到20%或更高,而在普通人群中这一比例要低得多,为3%-5%。研究表明,诸如口服托吡酯或肌肉注射A型肉毒毒素(保妥适)等药物已被用于预防CM,并且枕神经阻滞已被证明有助于治疗枕神经痛和短期缓解CM。然而,尚无已知研究专门评估在美国退伍军人中使用保妥适和枕神经阻滞来降低头痛频率的情况。本研究的目的是评估使用枕神经阻滞和保妥适作为双重疗法降低患有CM、枕神经痛且有创伤性脑损伤或颈部创伤病史的9·11事件后的退伍军人头痛频率的有效性。
经机构审查委员会批准后,对在德克萨斯州中部退伍军人医疗保健系统的头痛诊所接受治疗的9·11事件后的退伍军人进行了回顾性病历审查。使用电子病历检索符合以下条件的9·11事件后的退伍军人病历:(1)有确诊的与部署相关的创伤性脑损伤或颈部创伤病史;(2)被诊断为CM和枕神经痛;(3)在2014年1月1日至2015年12月31日期间在头痛诊所接受治疗,且在前六个月内接受了枕神经阻滞和保妥适治疗。在审查的282份病历中,共有30名(N = 30)退伍军人符合标准。将开始治疗前一个月(28天)自我报告的每月头痛天数平均值与治疗开始后6个月(28天)每月的头痛天数进行比较。
结果显示,治疗前一个月的平均头痛天数为24.1(22.0,25.7)。治疗后一个月(枕神经阻滞和保妥适双重治疗开始后6个月)的平均头痛天数为12.9(9.7,16.4)。治疗前后头痛天数的平均差异(治疗前减去治疗后)为11.2(8.2,14.2)。
本研究评估了使用枕神经阻滞和保妥适作为双重疗法降低患有CM、枕神经痛且有创伤性脑损伤或颈部创伤病史的9·11事件后的退伍军人头痛频率的有效性。结果显示双重治疗后每月头痛天数有统计学意义的减少。该研究存在多个局限性,包括样本量小、缺乏对照组、仅在治疗前和治疗后1个月自我报告头痛情况,以及未对可能影响结果的其他干预措施或事件进行控制。非常需要针对该人群进行涉及双重疗法的随机、双盲、安慰剂对照研究。本研究虽然规模小,但可能有助于推动针对该退伍军人人群的更多研究和治疗。