Department of Health Policy and Administration, College of Health and Human Development, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania, USA.
Division of Health Policy and Management, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA.
Health Econ. 2019 Apr;28(4):517-528. doi: 10.1002/hec.3860. Epub 2019 Jan 29.
Hospital-physician integration has substantially grown in the United States for the past decade, particularly in certain medical specialties, such as oncology. Yet evidence is scarce on the relation between integration and outpatient specialty care use and spending. We analyzed the impact of oncologist integration on outpatient provider-administered chemotherapy use and spending in Medicare, where prices do not depend on providers' integration status or negotiating power. We addressed oncologists' selective integration and patients' nonrandom choice of oncologists using an instrumental variables method. We found that integrated oncologists reduced the quantity of outpatient chemotherapy drugs but used more expensive treatments. This led to an increase in chemotherapy-drug spending after integration. These findings suggest that changes in treatment patterns-treatment mix and quantity-may be an important mechanism by which integration increases spending. We also found that integration increased spending on chemotherapy administration (the act of injection). This is because integration shifted billing of chemotherapy to hospital outpatient departments, where Medicare payments for chemotherapy administration are higher than those in physician offices. As integration increases, efforts should continue to assess how integration influences patient care and explore policy options to ensure desirable outcomes from integration.
在过去的十年中,美国的医院-医师整合有了实质性的增长,特别是在某些医学专业领域,如肿瘤学。然而,关于整合与门诊专科护理的使用和支出之间的关系,证据还很少。我们分析了肿瘤学家整合对医疗保险中门诊提供者管理的化疗使用和支出的影响,在医疗保险中,价格不取决于提供者的整合状况或谈判能力。我们使用工具变量法解决了肿瘤学家选择性整合和患者非随机选择肿瘤学家的问题。我们发现,整合后的肿瘤学家减少了门诊化疗药物的数量,但使用了更昂贵的治疗方法。这导致整合后化疗药物支出增加。这些发现表明,治疗模式的变化——治疗组合和数量——可能是整合增加支出的一个重要机制。我们还发现,整合增加了化疗给药(注射行为)的支出。这是因为整合将化疗计费转移到了医院门诊部门,而医疗保险对化疗给药的支付在医院门诊部门比在医生办公室更高。随着整合的增加,应继续评估整合如何影响患者护理,并探索政策选择,以确保整合产生理想的结果。