Ohta Ryuichi, Kamiyama Yoshiyuki, Makishi Tomoyuki
a Community Care , Unnan City Hospital , Japan.
b Okinawa Chubu Hospital , Japan.
Educ Prim Care. 2019 Mar;30(2):88-95. doi: 10.1080/14739879.2019.1570350. Epub 2019 Jan 30.
Community-based medical education (CBME) improves the learning of medical students. The outcomes depend on the circumstances in which students learn. So far, there has been no study on the short-term learning experienced by medical students on rural islands in Japan; hence, we specifically explored this in the case of islands in Okinawa.
We conducted one-on-one semi-structured interviews with seven medical students and three focus groups, each comprising three medical students. All subjects underwent a three-day clinical training on the rural islands of Okinawa, Japan. All sessions were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. We analysed the contents of the interview using the Steps for Coding and Theorisation.
Ten concepts were extracted and four themes generated: 1) rural resources and environments, 2) interaction with inhabitants, 3) rural physicians' skills, and 4) proposed revisions. These themes and concepts provide valuable insights into the dynamics of medical care on rural islands as well as the benefit of this experience for students trained in urban contexts. The participants learned the importance of collaborating with multiple professionals in ways specific to each rural context. By interacting with various islanders, they developed an understanding of the different cultural backgrounds in which rural physicians work and their ability to adapt to each. This experience motivated them to pursue studies on rural medicine upon return to the mainland.
This study shows that a short-term learning experience on rural islands in Japan may help medical students understand specific rural resources and their importance, the interconnections among the inhabitants, and the competency of primary care physicians.
基于社区的医学教育(CBME)可提高医学生的学习效果。其结果取决于学生学习的环境。到目前为止,尚未有关于日本农村岛屿医学生短期学习经历的研究;因此,我们专门针对冲绳的岛屿进行了此项探索。
我们对七名医学生进行了一对一的半结构化访谈,并组织了三个焦点小组,每个小组由三名医学生组成。所有受试者都在日本冲绳的农村岛屿接受了为期三天的临床培训。所有访谈均进行了录音并逐字转录。我们使用编码和理论化步骤对访谈内容进行了分析。
提取了十个概念并生成了四个主题:1)农村资源与环境,2)与居民的互动,3)农村医生的技能,4)提出的改进建议。这些主题和概念为农村岛屿医疗的动态情况以及这种经历对在城市环境中接受培训的学生的益处提供了宝贵的见解。参与者了解了根据每个农村环境的具体情况与多个专业人员合作的重要性。通过与不同的岛民互动,他们对农村医生工作所处的不同文化背景以及适应每种背景的能力有了认识。这段经历促使他们回到大陆后继续研究农村医学。
本研究表明,在日本农村岛屿的短期学习经历可能有助于医学生了解特定的农村资源及其重要性、居民之间的相互联系以及基层医疗医生的能力。