Kashtanova S Yu, Mironova N A, Shitov V N, Gupalo E M, Kiktev V G, Saidova M A, Golitsyn S P
A.L. Myasnikov Institute of Clinical Cardiology, National Medical Research Center for Cardiology of the Ministry of Health of the Russian -Federation, Moscow, Russia.
Ter Arkh. 2018 Dec 30;90(12):76-83. doi: 10.26442/00403660.2018.12.000012.
To assess the value of the complex analysis of electrocardiographic (ECG) variants and echocardiographic (echo) manifestation of left bundle branch block (LBBB) in predicting the success of cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT).
The study included 39 patients (mean age 61.49±9.0 years) on sinus rhythm with LBBB, QRS duration ≥130 ms, left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) ≤35%, heart failure (HF) NYHA II-IV despite optimal pharmacological therapy during 3 month. All patients had undergone CRT-D implantation. Depending on presence or absence of ECG-criteria, proposed by D.G. Strauss et al., patients were divided into 2 groups: 1 group - strict LBBB, proposed by D.G. Strauss et al. (n=29) and 2 group - other patients (n=10). In addition to standard echocardiography, global longitudinal 2-dimensional strain (GLS) and LBBB contraction pattern have been performed initially and in 6 months after implantation. Response to CRT was defined as decrease in LV end-systolic volume by >15% after 6 months of follow-up.
Typical LBBB echo contraction pattern was detected in 25 patients (64% of all included). These patients had more pronounced longitudinal dissynchrony and a more expressed global longitudinal strain before CPT-D implantation (p<0.05). 27 patients (69% of all included) were included in the "response" group, the remaining 12 patients (31% of all included) - the "non-response" group. In the "response" group the morphology of the QRS complex was significantly more likely to meet the criteria, proposed by D.G. Strauss et al., than other variants (23 vs. 6, respectively, p=0.02), and the echo contraction pattern of this patients more often corresponded to "typical" LBBB (24 vs. 1, p=0.001). All patients, who had the ECG criteria, proposed by D.G. Strauss et al., and echo "typical" LBBB contraction pattern, responded on CPT. Moreover, the proportion of these patients in the "response" group was rather high - 81.5% (22 of 27 patients).
ECG criteria LBBB, proposed by D.G. Strauss et al., identify patients with delayed transseptal interventricular conduction due to complete LBBB, what is a good target for CPT. Evaluation of the echo contraction pattern based on the definition of longitudinal myocardial deformation by means of a two-dimensional strand technology allows predicting the success of CPT in patients with LBBB. Patients with «typical» LBBB contraction pattern show more pronounced global longitudinal strain and larger longitudinal dissynchrony compared with other patients, and it explains their better response to CPT. Complex analysis of strict LBBB ECG criteria and echo contraction pattern are promising parameters in predicting beneficial response to CRT in patients with HF.
评估心电图(ECG)变异与左束支传导阻滞(LBBB)的超声心动图(echo)表现的综合分析在预测心脏再同步治疗(CRT)成功率方面的价值。
该研究纳入了39例窦性心律的患者(平均年龄61.49±9.0岁),这些患者患有LBBB,QRS时限≥130毫秒,左心室射血分数(LVEF)≤35%,尽管在3个月内进行了最佳药物治疗,但仍有纽约心脏协会(NYHA)II-IV级心力衰竭(HF)。所有患者均接受了CRT-D植入。根据D.G. Strauss等人提出的ECG标准的有无,将患者分为2组:1组 - D.G. Strauss等人提出的严格LBBB(n = 29)和2组 - 其他患者(n = 10)。除了标准超声心动图外,还在植入前及植入后6个月进行了整体纵向二维应变(GLS)和LBBB收缩模式检查。CRT反应定义为随访6个月后左心室收缩末期容积减少>15%。
25例患者(占所有纳入患者的64%)检测到典型的LBBB回声收缩模式。这些患者在CRT-D植入前有更明显的纵向不同步和更明显的整体纵向应变(p<0.05)。27例患者(占所有纳入患者的69%)被纳入“反应”组,其余12例患者(占所有纳入患者 的31%) - “无反应”组。在“反应”组中,QRS波群形态比其他变异更有可能符合D.G. Strauss等人提出的标准(分别为23例对6例,p = 0.02),并且该组患者的回声收缩模式更常符合“典型”LBBB(24例对1例,p = 0.001)。所有符合D.G. Strauss等人提出的ECG标准且回声为“典型”LBBB收缩模式的患者对CRT有反应。此外,这些患者在“反应”组中的比例相当高 - 81.5%(27例患者中的22例)。
D.G. Strauss等人提出的LBBB的ECG标准可识别由于完全性LBBB导致经间隔心室传导延迟的患者,这是CRT的良好靶点。基于二维应变技术定义纵向心肌变形来评估回声收缩模式,能够预测LBBB患者CRT的成功率。与其他患者相比,具有“典型”LBBB收缩模式的患者表现出更明显的整体纵向应变和更大的纵向不同步,这解释了他们对CRT的更好反应。严格的LBBB ECG标准和回声收缩模式的综合分析是预测HF患者对CRT有益反应的有前景的参数。