Laboratoire de Sociologie et d'Anthropologie (LaSA, EA3189), University of Burgundy Franche-Comté, Besançon, France.
Clinical Investigation Center, Inserm 1431, CHRU Besançon, Besançon, France.
Eur J Hum Genet. 2019 May;27(5):701-710. doi: 10.1038/s41431-018-0332-y. Epub 2019 Feb 1.
Exome sequencing (ES) has revolutionized diagnostic procedures in medical genetics, particularly for developmental diseases. The variety and complexity of the information produced has raised issues regarding its use in a clinical setting. Of particular interest are patients' expectations regarding the information disclosed, the accompaniment provided, and the value patients place on these. To explore these issues in parents of children with developmental disorders and no diagnosis with known etiology, a multidisciplinary group of researchers from social and behavioral sciences and patient organizations conducted a mixed-methodology study (quantitative and qualitative) in two centers of expertise for rare diseases in France. The quantitative study aimed to determine the preferences of 513 parents regarding the disclosure of ES results. It showed that parents wished to have exhaustive information, including variants of unknown significance possibly linked to their child's disorder and secondary findings. This desire for information could be a strategy to maximize the chances of obtaining a diagnosis. The qualitative study aimed to understand the expectations and reactions of 57 parents interviewed just after the return of ES results. In-depth analysis showed that parents had ambivalent feelings about the findings whatever the results returned. The contrasting results from these studies raise questions about the value of the information provided and parents' high expectations regarding the results. The nature of parental expectations has emerged as an important topic in efforts to optimize accompaniment and support for families during the informed decision-making process and after disclosure of the results in an overall context of uncertainty.
外显子组测序(ES)在医学遗传学诊断程序方面带来了革命性的变化,尤其对于发育性疾病。所产生的信息的多样性和复杂性引发了一些问题,涉及到其在临床环境中的应用。特别引人关注的是患者对所披露信息、提供的伴随服务以及患者对这些信息的重视程度的期望。为了探讨这一问题,来自社会和行为科学以及患者组织的多学科研究团队在法国两个罕见病专业中心对患有发育障碍且病因不明的儿童的父母进行了一项混合方法研究(定量和定性)。定量研究旨在确定 513 名父母对 ES 结果披露的偏好。研究表明,父母希望获得详尽的信息,包括可能与孩子疾病相关的意义未明的变异和次要发现。这种对信息的渴望可能是最大化获得诊断机会的一种策略。定性研究旨在了解 57 名接受 ES 结果返回后访谈的父母的期望和反应。深入分析表明,无论结果如何,父母对发现都存在矛盾的感受。这些研究的对比结果引发了关于所提供信息的价值以及父母对结果的高度期望的问题。父母期望的本质已成为在不确定的总体背景下,优化知情决策过程中对家庭的陪伴和支持以及结果披露后的重要议题。