Internal Medicine, University of Edinburgh Royal Dick School of Veterinary Studies, Easter Bush, UK.
Vet Rec. 2019 Mar 2;184(9):283. doi: 10.1136/vr.104774. Epub 2019 Feb 2.
To evaluate whether a standard operating procedure (SOP) for canine packed cell volume (PCV) measurement reduces operator-dependent variation and improves accuracy within a veterinary teaching hospital environment.
Clinical staff and final-year undergraduate veterinary students were recruited to perform PCV measurements in blinded duplicate samples. Participants were randomly allocated to perform this with or without an SOP. Participants' results were compared against a reference, generated by the authors following the World Health Organization guidelines.
The study population comprised 18 clinical staff and 39 students. Three clinical staff and seven students displayed errors consistent with inaccurate reading, only one of whom had access to the SOP. Five students and two clinical staff had errors attributable to incorrect preparation, with only one having access to the SOP. Interoperator variation was significantly less using the SOP. Using the SOP, 95 per cent of the results were within 0.0125 l/l of the reference value, in comparison with within 0.09 l/l without SOP. Interoperator variation was significantly less in the SOP group (P=0.0025).
Using the SOP resulted in less variation and more accurate results. This confirms that PCV measurement with an SOP can truly be a 'waived' test.
评估犬红细胞压积(PCV)测量的标准操作程序(SOP)是否可以减少操作人员依赖性的变化并提高兽医教学医院环境内的准确性。
临床工作人员和兽医本科最后一年的学生被招募来进行盲样重复 PCV 测量。参与者被随机分配使用或不使用 SOP 进行此操作。将参与者的结果与作者根据世界卫生组织指南生成的参考值进行比较。
研究人群包括 18 名临床工作人员和 39 名学生。3 名临床工作人员和 7 名学生的读数存在不准确的错误,其中只有 1 人可以使用 SOP。5 名学生和 2 名临床工作人员的错误归因于不正确的准备,其中只有 1 人可以使用 SOP。使用 SOP 时,95%的结果与参考值相差 0.0125 l/l,而没有 SOP 时相差 0.09 l/l。使用 SOP 时,操作者之间的差异明显较小(P=0.0025)。
使用 SOP 可减少差异并获得更准确的结果。这证实了使用 SOP 进行 PCV 测量确实可以成为一种“豁免”测试。