Department of Anthropology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio.
Division of Health Sciences, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 2019 Mar;168(3):595-605. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.23776. Epub 2019 Feb 4.
Previous work by Vercellotti et al. in 2011 found significant status-related differences in body size in males but not in females from the Italian bioarchaeological assemblage of San Michele di Trino (8th-14th centuries CE). The purpose of the present work is twofold: (a) to determine if status-related body size differences could be observed in the nearby collection of San Lorenzo di Alba (7th-15th centuries CE) and (b) to add to the emerging narrative of medieval Italians.
Osteometric data (maximum length for the humerus, radius, ulna, femur, tibia, and fibula; bicondylar length of the femur, condylo-malleolar length of the tibia, foot height, maximum vertebral heights, and basion-bregma height) were collected for 50 (20 female, 30 male) individuals from Alba, and Monte Carlo analysis was used to assess differences in skeletal element size, skeletal height, living stature, and body mass across sex and status.
Significant differences were detected between high status and low status males in Alba for radial maximum length (p = 0.013), tibial maximum length (p = 0.011), tibial condylo-malleolar length (p = 0.012), skeletal height estimated from condylo-malleolar tibial length (p = 0.002), and stature estimated from condyle-malleolar tibial length with the age component (p = 0.003). In contrast, no significant status-based differences were observed between female subsamples (p > 0.05).
The patterns of intrapopulation variation observed at Alba are similar but not as pronounced as those observed at Trino, suggesting that overall life conditions experienced by the two groups were comparable.
2011 年,Vercellotti 等人的研究发现,意大利圣米凯莱迪特里诺(公元 8 世纪至 14 世纪)生物考古组合中男性的体型存在显著的与地位相关的差异,但女性则没有。本研究的目的有两个:(a)确定在附近的圣洛伦佐迪阿尔巴(公元 7 世纪至 15 世纪)收藏中是否可以观察到与地位相关的体型差异;(b)补充正在出现的中世纪意大利人的叙述。
对阿尔巴的 50 名(20 名女性,30 名男性)个体的骨骼进行了骨骼测量数据(肱骨、桡骨、尺骨、股骨、胫骨和腓骨的最大长度;股骨的双髁长度、胫骨的踝间长度、足高、最大椎体高度和基线-鼻根高度)收集,并使用蒙特卡罗分析评估了性别和地位对骨骼元素大小、骨骼高度、活体身高和体重的影响。
在阿尔巴,高地位和低地位的男性在桡骨最大长度(p=0.013)、胫骨最大长度(p=0.011)、胫骨踝间长度(p=0.012)、根据胫骨踝间长度估计的骨骼高度(p=0.002)和根据胫骨踝间长度和年龄成分估计的身高(p=0.003)方面存在显著差异。相比之下,女性亚组之间没有观察到显著的基于地位的差异(p>0.05)。
在阿尔巴观察到的群体内变异模式与在特里诺观察到的模式相似,但不如特里诺明显,这表明这两个群体所经历的整体生活条件相当。