Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, United States of America.
School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs and School of Criminology and Criminal Justice, Northeastern University, Boston, MA, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2019 Feb 4;14(2):e0211350. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0211350. eCollection 2019.
Much research has examined how crime rates vary across urban neighborhoods, focusing particularly on community-level demographic and social characteristics. A parallel line of work has treated crime at the individual level as an expression of certain behavioral patterns (e.g., impulsivity). Little work has considered, however, whether the prevalence of such behavioral patterns in a neighborhood might be predictive of local crime, in large part because such measures are hard to come by and often subjective. The Facebook Advertising API offers a special opportunity to examine this question as it provides an extensive list of "interests" that can be tabulated at various geographic scales. Here we conduct an analysis of the association between the prevalence of interests among the Facebook population of a ZIP code and the local rate of assaults, burglaries, and robberies across 9 highly populated cities in the US. We fit various regression models to predict crime rates as a function of the Facebook and census demographic variables. In general, models using the variables for the interests of the whole adult population on Facebook perform better than those using data on specific demographic groups (such as Males 18-34). In terms of predictive performance, models combining Facebook data with demographic data generally have lower error rates than models using only demographic data. We find that interests associated with media consumption and mating competition are predictive of crime rates above and beyond demographic factors. We discuss how this might integrate with existing criminological theory.
许多研究都考察了犯罪率在城市社区之间的差异,特别关注社区层面的人口和社会特征。另一系列研究则将个体层面的犯罪视为某些行为模式(如冲动)的表现。然而,很少有研究考虑到一个社区中此类行为模式的流行程度是否可以预测当地的犯罪率,这在很大程度上是因为这些措施很难获得,而且往往是主观的。Facebook 广告 API 提供了一个特殊的机会来检验这个问题,因为它提供了一个广泛的“兴趣”列表,可以在不同的地理尺度上进行统计。在这里,我们分析了一个邮政编码的 Facebook 人群中“兴趣”的流行程度与美国 9 个人口众多的城市的当地袭击、盗窃和抢劫率之间的关联。我们拟合了各种回归模型,以预测犯罪率作为 Facebook 和人口普查人口统计学变量的函数。一般来说,使用 Facebook 上所有成年人口的变量的模型比使用特定人口统计学群体(如 18-34 岁男性)数据的模型表现更好。就预测性能而言,将 Facebook 数据与人口统计学数据相结合的模型通常比仅使用人口统计学数据的模型具有更低的错误率。我们发现,与媒体消费和交配竞争相关的兴趣可以预测犯罪率,而不仅仅是人口统计学因素。我们讨论了这如何与现有的犯罪学理论相结合。