Fang Sai-Nan, Bai Xue, Yang Si-Hong, Feng Xue, Liao Xing, Liu Jian-Ping, Chen Wei
Centre for Evidence-Based Chinese Medicine, Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, Beijing 100029, China.
Standardization Department, China Association of Chinese Medicine, Beijing 100029, China.
Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi. 2018 Dec;43(24):4796-4800. doi: 10.19540/j.cnki.cjcmm.2018.0127.
Due to its own characteristics and research status, traditional Chinese medicine research often faces the reality of "insufficient evidence" or "very low quality" when making clinical practice guidelines. Therefore, in many cases, clinical decision-making of traditional Chinese medicine should rely mainly on expert consensus to achieve. A clear and detailed list of expert consensus report specifications will provide a good reporting tool for Chinese clinical expert consensus makers, which is very important for promoting the quality of consensus production and the promotion and application of consensus results. The author consulted the internationally published authoritative expert consensus, summarized the main points of the reports, combined with the formulation process of the clinical experts consensus of Chinese medicine, and the demonstration of clinical experts and methodologists, and then formulated the list of items for clinical expert consensus reports adapt to the field of Chinese medicine. This article introduces the entire list of items and elaborates on the key parts. It is expected to provide reference for the standardization of future clinical expert consensus reports.
由于中医药自身特点及研究现状，中医药研究在制定临床实践指南时往往面临“证据不足”或“质量极低”的现实情况。因此，在很多情况下，中医药临床决策主要应依靠专家共识来实现。一份清晰、详细的专家共识报告规范清单将为我国临床专家共识制定者提供良好的报告工具，这对于提高共识制定质量以及共识结果的推广应用非常重要。作者查阅了国际上发表的权威专家共识，总结报告要点，结合中医临床专家共识的制定过程以及临床专家和方法学家的论证，进而制定了适用于中医药领域的临床专家共识报告条目清单。本文介绍了条目清单全貌并对关键部分进行阐述，期望能为未来临床专家共识报告的规范化提供参考。
