Department of Neurosurgery, University Hospital of Zurich, Frauenklinikstrasse 10, 8091, Zurich, Switzerland.
Neurosurg Rev. 2019 Sep;42(3):721-729. doi: 10.1007/s10143-019-01081-9. Epub 2019 Feb 6.
Intra-axial brainstem surgeries are challenging. Many experience-based "safe entry zones (SEZs)" into brainstem lesions have been proposed in the existing literature. The evidence for each one seems limited. English-language publications were retrieved using PubMed/MEDLINE. Studies that focused only on cadaveric anatomy were also included, but the clinical case number was treated as zero. The clinical evidence level was defined as "case report" when the surgical case number was ≤ 5, "limited evidence" when there were more than 5 but less than 25 cases, and "credible evidence" when a publication presented more than 25 cases. Twenty-five out of 32 publications were included, and 21 different SEZs were found for the brainstem: six SEZs were located in the midbrain, 9 SEZs in the pons, and 6 SEZs in the medulla. Case report evidence was found for 10 SEZs, and limited evidence for 7 SEZs. Four SEZs were determined to be backed by credible evidence. The proposed SEZs came from initial cadaveric anatomy studies, followed by some published clinical experience. Only a few SEZs have elevated clinical evidence. The choice of the right approach into the brainstem remains a challenge in each case.
脑内轴性手术极具挑战性。许多基于经验的“安全入区(SEZ)”已在现有文献中被提出。但每一种方法的证据似乎都很有限。使用 PubMed/MEDLINE 检索英文文献。也包括仅关注尸体解剖的研究,但将临床病例数视为零。当手术病例数≤5 时,临床证据水平定义为“病例报告”,当有超过 5 但少于 25 个病例时为“有限证据”,当出版物中有超过 25 个病例时为“可信证据”。32 篇文章中有 25 篇被纳入,在脑干中发现了 21 个不同的 SEZ:6 个 SEZ 位于中脑,9 个 SEZ 位于脑桥,6 个 SEZ 位于延髓。有 10 个 SEZ 的证据为病例报告,7 个 SEZ 的证据为有限。有 4 个 SEZ 被认为有可靠的证据支持。提出的 SEZ 来自最初的尸体解剖研究,随后有一些发表的临床经验。只有少数 SEZ 具有较高的临床证据。在每种情况下,选择进入脑干的正确方法仍然是一个挑战。