School of Biomedical Engineering and Health Sciences, Faculty of Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310, Johor Bahru, Johor, Malaysia.
School of Sport, Exercise, and Rehabilitation Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Med Biol Eng Comput. 2019 Jun;57(6):1229-1245. doi: 10.1007/s11517-019-01958-3. Epub 2019 Feb 7.
Adverse childhood experiences have been suggested to cause changes in physiological processes and can determine the magnitude of the stress response which might have a significant impact on health later in life. To detect the stress response, biomarkers that represent both the Autonomic Nervous System (ANS) and Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal (HPA) axis are proposed. Among the available biomarkers, Heart Rate Variability (HRV) has been proven as a powerful biomarker that represents ANS. Meanwhile, salivary cortisol has been suggested as a biomarker that reflects the HPA axis. Even though many studies used multiple biomarkers to measure the stress response, the results for each biomarker were analyzed separately. Therefore, the objective of this study is to propose a fusion of ANS and HPA axis biomarkers in order to classify the stress response based on adverse childhood experience. Electrocardiograph, blood pressure (BP), pulse rate (PR), and salivary cortisol (SCort) measures were collected from 23 healthy participants; 11 participants had adverse childhood experience while the remaining 12 acted as the no adversity control group. HRV was then computed from the ECG and the HRV features were extracted. Next, the selected HRV features were combined with the other biomarkers using Euclidean distance (e) and serial fusion, and the performance of the fused features was compared using Support Vector Machine. From the result, HRV-SCort using Euclidean distance achieved the most satisfactory performance with 80.0% accuracy, 83.3% sensitivity, and 78.3% specificity. Furthermore, the performance of the stress response classification of the fused biomarker, HRV-SCort, outperformed that of the single biomarkers: HRV (61% Accuracy), Cort (59.4% Accuracy), BP (78.3% accuracy), and PR (53.3% accuracy). From this study, it was proven that the fused biomarkers that represent both ANS and HPA (HRV-SCort) able to demonstrate a better classification performance in discriminating the stress response. Furthermore, a new approach for classification of stress response using Euclidean distance and SVM named as e-SVM was proven to be an effective method for the HRV-SCort in classifying the stress response from PASAT. The robustness of this method is crucial in contributing to the effectiveness of the stress response measures and could further be used as an indicator for future health. Graphical abstract ᅟ.
不良的童年经历被认为会导致生理过程发生变化,并决定压力反应的程度,而这可能会对以后的健康产生重大影响。为了检测压力反应,提出了代表自主神经系统 (ANS) 和下丘脑-垂体-肾上腺 (HPA) 轴的生物标志物。在可用的生物标志物中,心率变异性 (HRV) 已被证明是代表 ANS 的强大生物标志物。同时,唾液皮质醇被认为是反映 HPA 轴的生物标志物。尽管许多研究使用多种生物标志物来测量压力反应,但每个生物标志物的结果都是分别分析的。因此,本研究的目的是提出将 ANS 和 HPA 轴生物标志物融合在一起,以便根据不良的童年经历对压力反应进行分类。从 23 名健康参与者中收集了心电图、血压 (BP)、脉搏率 (PR) 和唾液皮质醇 (SCort) 测量值;11 名参与者有不良的童年经历,而其余 12 名参与者作为无逆境对照组。然后从心电图中计算出 HRV,并提取 HRV 特征。接下来,使用欧几里得距离 (e) 和串联融合将选定的 HRV 特征与其他生物标志物相结合,并使用支持向量机比较融合特征的性能。结果表明,使用欧几里得距离的 HRV-SCort 达到了 80.0%的准确率、83.3%的灵敏度和 78.3%的特异性,性能最佳。此外,融合生物标志物 HRV-SCort 的压力反应分类性能优于单个生物标志物:HRV(61%的准确率)、Cort(59.4%的准确率)、BP(78.3%的准确率)和 PR(53.3%的准确率)。本研究证明,代表 ANS 和 HPA 的融合生物标志物(HRV-SCort)能够更好地展示分类性能在区分压力反应。此外,一种使用欧几里得距离和 SVM 的新的压力反应分类方法,即 e-SVM,已被证明是一种有效的方法,用于将 HRV-SCort 从 PASAT 中分类压力反应。该方法的稳健性对于提高压力反应测量的有效性至关重要,并可进一步用作未来健康的指标。