University College Absalon, Trekroner Forskerpark 4, DK-4000 Roskilde, Denmark.
Nurse Educ Today. 2019 May;76:31-37. doi: 10.1016/j.nedt.2019.01.019. Epub 2019 Feb 6.
The balance between lessons prepared to challenge the talented students and students who find the courses difficult is a recurrent dilemma in the Danish nurse education. Challenging talented students while pitching the learning appropriately for less able students is a recurring dilemma in education. In Danish nursing courses, the gap between these two kinds of student becomes particularly obvious in fifth semester theoretical courses.
To provide knowledge of students' experiences of challenging courses a phenomenological approach was adopted. Nine fifth semester nursing students participated. Data were generated through photo-elicitation, which proceeded in two steps. Firstly, nursing students were invited to take photos of NO-situations, i.e. situations they considered to be boring, difficult, annoying or confusing, and YES-situations, which they considered to be cool, awesome, interesting, exciting, encouraging, etc. Secondly, the students presented their photos at a workshop, where they described the background of the photos. In reflecting teams, they reflected on the stories and discussed whether they recognised the situations and could relate them to their own experiences. The stories, reflections and discussions were audio recorded and transcribed.
A phenomenological analysis revealed three themes. The first theme It is hard to crack the code was characterised by a feeling of insecurity in facing unknown words and concepts that were far from what they normally associated with nursing. The second theme When the students succeeded in cracking the code was characterised by the feeling of joy and relief when they grasped the meaning and understood the links to nursing practice. The third theme Sources of irritation and frustration was characterised by various disturbances, lack of mutual respect and practical challenges. The paper also adds to the field of elicitation methods the combination of photo-elicitation and reflecting teams.
在为有天赋的学生准备具有挑战性的课程和为学习困难的学生提供适当课程之间取得平衡,是丹麦护理教育中反复出现的困境。在教育中,既要挑战有天赋的学生,又要为能力较弱的学生提供适当的学习,这是一个反复出现的困境。在丹麦护理课程中,这种学生之间的差距在第五学期的理论课程中尤为明显。
为了了解学生对具有挑战性课程的体验,采用了现象学方法。9 名第五学期护理学生参与了研究。通过照片引发法生成数据,该方法分两步进行。首先,邀请护理学生拍摄他们认为无聊的、困难的、烦人的或困惑的 NO 情境,以及他们认为酷的、令人敬畏的、有趣的、令人兴奋的、鼓舞人心的等 YES 情境。其次,学生在研讨会上展示他们的照片,并描述照片的背景。在反思小组中,他们反思故事并讨论他们是否认识到这些情况,以及是否能将其与自己的经验联系起来。故事、反思和讨论都被录音并转录。
现象学分析揭示了三个主题。第一个主题是“破解密码很难”,其特点是面对远离他们通常与护理相关的陌生单词和概念时感到不安。第二个主题是“当学生成功破解密码时”,其特点是当他们理解了含义并理解了与护理实践的联系时,感到喜悦和宽慰。第三个主题是“烦躁和沮丧的根源”,其特点是各种干扰、缺乏相互尊重和实际挑战。本文还在引发方法领域增加了照片引发法和反思小组的结合。