Mollabashi Vahid, Soltani Mohammad Karim, Moslemian Naeime, Akhlaghian Marzieh, Akbarzadeh Mahdi, Samavat Hesamoddin, Abolvardi Masoud
Department of orthodontics, Dental research center, Hamadan university of medical sciences, Hamadan, Iran.
Dental research center, dentistry research institute, department of prosthodontics, school of dentistry, Tehran university of medical sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Int Orthod. 2019 Mar;17(1):143-150. doi: 10.1016/j.ortho.2019.01.005. Epub 2019 Feb 13.
Bolton ratio is used as a method for diagnosis of tooth size discrepancy. Tooth size discrepancy has an important role in the stability of results of final orthodontic treatment. The aim of this study was to determine and compare Bolton ratio in normal occlusion and different malocclusion groups of Iranian population.
This descriptive-analytic study comprises 240 orthodontic patient casts (for every malocclusion group: class I, class II division 1, class II division 2, class III, 30 males and 30 females) which have fully erupted and complete permanent dentitions from first molar to first molar, and also 60 persons (30 male-30 female) with normal occlusion. The mesiodistal tooth sizes were measured using digital caliper two times with a 4-week interval.
The average mesiodistal size of all teeth in the malocclusion group was significantly bigger than in the normal occlusion group. Although there was no relationship between anterior ratio and gender or malocclusion groups, but a significant relationship between total ratio in Class II division 1 and normal occlusion was seen. Furthermore, a significant difference between anterior and total ratios in the present study and original Bolton's values was found.
In the normal occlusion group, the anterior and total ratios were bigger than those in Bolton's original study. Also, "class II division 1" showed the lowest values of Bolton ratio among the other normal occlusion and malocclusion groups. Therefore, the original Bolton's values should be used conservatively in Iranian population.
博尔顿比率用作诊断牙齿大小不调的一种方法。牙齿大小不调在正畸治疗最终结果的稳定性方面具有重要作用。本研究的目的是确定并比较伊朗人群正常咬合及不同错牙合畸形组的博尔顿比率。
这项描述性分析研究包括240例正畸患者的模型(每个错牙合畸形组:安氏I类、安氏II类1分类、安氏II类2分类、安氏III类,男性30例,女性30例),这些模型的恒牙从第一磨牙到第一磨牙均已完全萌出且完整,还有60例(男性30例 - 女性30例)正常咬合者。使用数字卡尺以4周的间隔对牙齿的近远中径进行了两次测量。
错牙合畸形组所有牙齿的平均近远中径显著大于正常咬合组。虽然前牙比率与性别或错牙合畸形组之间没有关系,但在安氏II类1分类与正常咬合的总比率之间存在显著关系。此外,本研究中的前牙比率和总比率与原始博尔顿值之间存在显著差异。
在正常咬合组中,前牙比率和总比率大于博尔顿原始研究中的值。此外,在其他正常咬合和错牙合畸形组中,“安氏II类1分类”的博尔顿比率值最低。因此,在伊朗人群中应谨慎使用博尔顿原始值。