Csako G, Zweig M H, Benson C, Ruddel M
Clin Chem. 1986 Jan;32(1 Pt 1):108-15.
We evaluated three one-step (analog) and two two-step radioimmunoassay for free thyroxin (FT4), and a FT4 index calculated from the total T4 (TT4) and thyroxin-binding globulin (TBG) ratio for technical performance, for correlation with the reference FT4 method (equilibrium dialysis), and for dependence on TBG and albumin concentrations. The one-step methods (Amerlex, Coat-A-Count, and GammaCoat) showed greater precision than the two-step procedures (GammaCoat and Spiria). Results by the latter two techniques, however, correlated better with those by equilibrium dialysis than did those by the analog methods or by TT4/TBG. Only the GammaCoat two-step method had a slight but statistically significant (inverse) correlation with TBG concentration. All three analog methods and TT4/TBG showed a marked dependence on albumin concentration, whereas the Spiria technique showed only a slight dependence. Only equilibrium dialysis was independent of both the TBG and albumin concentration. Thus, despite their good precision, the analog (one-step) FT4 methods and the TT4/TBG approach cannot be expected to produce valid results when the concentration of albumin in serum is abnormally low or high.
我们评估了三种一步法(模拟法)和两种两步法游离甲状腺素(FT4)放射免疫测定法,以及一种根据总甲状腺素(TT4)与甲状腺素结合球蛋白(TBG)比值计算得出的FT4指数,以评估其技术性能、与参考FT4方法(平衡透析法)的相关性以及对TBG和白蛋白浓度的依赖性。一步法(Amerlex、Coat-A-Count和GammaCoat)比两步法(GammaCoat和Spiria)具有更高的精密度。然而,后两种技术的结果与平衡透析法的结果相关性比模拟法或TT4/TBG与平衡透析法的结果相关性更好。只有GammaCoat两步法与TBG浓度存在轻微但具有统计学意义的(负)相关性。所有三种模拟法和TT4/TBG都显著依赖白蛋白浓度,而Spiria技术仅表现出轻微依赖性。只有平衡透析法不依赖TBG和白蛋白浓度。因此,尽管模拟法(一步法)FT4测定法和TT4/TBG方法具有良好的精密度,但当血清中白蛋白浓度异常低或高时,不能期望它们产生有效的结果。