Jangi Majid, Ebnehoseini Zahra, Sabbagh Mahin Ghorban, Khaleghi Ebrahim, Tara Mahmoud
Department of Medical Informatics, School of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Ghaem Hospital, Mashhad, Iran.
Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl. 2019 Jan-Feb;30(1):1-14.
Predicting the future of illness, a patient is facing helps the physicians to choose the best strategy to manage the disease. Models for predicting the readiness of candidates for kidney transplant can be very promising. This study sought to systematically review the predictive models and algorithms that assess the readiness of renal transplant candidates in different countries. This systematic review study was according to PRISMA-P protocol in PubMed and Science Direct databases and general search engines up to March 2017. Eligible studies were those that introduced a model to assess the readiness for renal transplantation of patients with chronic renal failure from cadavers and this assessment led to scoring prioritization or superiority among patients. We found 28 studies from 11 countries that met the search criteria and >50% of them were published from 2015 onward. Of the studies, nine models and algorithms were extracted that included 12 factors. Some models, including the European and Scandinavian models, were used jointly between different countries. All the models had at least four factors, and nearly 90% of the models considered four or five factors to measure kidney transplantation readiness. More than 50% of the models had age, dialysis duration, HLA type, and emergency status factors and, dialysis duration. Predictive models are important for renal transplant because of the significant reduction in number of cadavers and longer wait of candidates for a kidney transplant. Further studies can examine the effect of these models on the survival of the kidney transplant.
预测患者所面临疾病的未来发展,有助于医生选择最佳的疾病管理策略。预测肾移植候选者准备情况的模型可能非常有前景。本研究旨在系统回顾评估不同国家肾移植候选者准备情况的预测模型和算法。这项系统综述研究按照PRISMA-P协议在PubMed和ScienceDirect数据库以及通用搜索引擎中进行,截至2017年3月。符合条件的研究是那些引入模型来评估慢性肾衰竭患者接受尸体肾移植准备情况的研究,且这种评估导致了患者之间的评分优先排序或优势比较。我们从11个国家找到了28项符合搜索标准的研究,其中超过50%是2015年以后发表的。在这些研究中,提取了9个模型和算法,包含12个因素。一些模型,包括欧洲和斯堪的纳维亚模型,在不同国家联合使用。所有模型至少有4个因素,近90%的模型考虑4个或5个因素来衡量肾移植准备情况。超过50%的模型有年龄、透析时间、HLA类型和紧急状态因素以及透析时间。由于尸体数量显著减少以及肾移植候选者等待时间延长,预测模型对肾移植很重要。进一步的研究可以检验这些模型对肾移植存活的影响。