Krishnan Saloni, Sellars Elise, Wood Helena, Bishop Dorothy V M, Watkins Kate E
Department of Experimental Psychology, University of Oxford, Anna Watts Building, Radcliffe Observatory Quarter, Oxford OX2 6GG, UK.
R Soc Open Sci. 2018 Sep 5;5(9):171496. doi: 10.1098/rsos.171496. eCollection 2018 Sep.
Feedback is typically incorporated in word learning paradigms, in both research studies and commercial language learning apps. While the common-sense view is that feedback is helpful during learning, relatively little empirical evidence exists about the role of feedback in spoken vocabulary learning. Some work has suggested that long-term word learning is not enhanced by the presence of feedback, and that words are best learned implicitly. It is also plausible that feedback might have differential effects when learners focus on learning semantic facts, or when they focus on learning a new phonological sequence of sounds. In this study, we assess how providing evaluative (right/wrong) feedback on a spoken response influences two different components of vocabulary learning, the learning of a new phonological form, and the learning of a semantic property of the phonological form. We find that receiving evaluative feedback improves retention of phonological forms, but not of semantic facts.
反馈通常被纳入到单词学习范式中,无论是在研究中还是在商业语言学习应用程序中。虽然常识认为反馈在学习过程中是有帮助的,但关于反馈在口语词汇学习中的作用,实证证据相对较少。一些研究表明,反馈的存在并不会增强长期的单词学习,而且单词最好通过隐性学习来掌握。同样合理的是,当学习者专注于学习语义事实,或者专注于学习新的语音序列时,反馈可能会产生不同的效果。在本研究中,我们评估了对口语回答提供评价性(正确/错误)反馈如何影响词汇学习的两个不同组成部分,即新语音形式的学习和语音形式语义属性的学习。我们发现,接受评价性反馈可以提高语音形式的记忆,但对语义事实的记忆没有帮助。