Allen Alena
University of Memphis Cecil C. Humphreys School of Law.
Fordham Law Rev. 2018 Dec;87(3):1033-83.
When feminists began advocating for rape reform in the 1970s, the rape message was clear: rape was not a crime to be taken seriously because women lie. After decades of criminal law reform, the legal requirement that a woman vigorously resist a man's sexual advances to prove that she was raped has largely disappeared from the statute books, and, in theory, rape shield laws make a woman's prior sexual history irrelevant. Yet, despite what the law dictates, rape law reforms have not had a "trickle-down" effect, where changes in law lead to changes in attitude. Women are still believed to be vindictive shrews so police continue to code rape allegations as "unfounded," and prosecutors continue to elect not to prosecute many rape cases. To many, "no" can sometimes still mean "yes." In short, criminal law reforms have only marginally succeeded at deterring rape and increasing conviction rates for rape. At the same time, criminal law reforms have entrenched gender norms and endorsed the message that acquaintance rapes are less worthy of harsh punishment. This Article argues against further ex post criminal law reforms and posits that efforts should shift to ex ante public health interventions. This Article draws from recent successful experiences with public health interventions in destigmatizing AIDS and denormalizing tobacco and advocates for a robust public health campaign to denormalize rape. It presents a detailed proposal for changing rape messaging, denormalizing rape, and ensuring better outcomes for victims.
20世纪70年代,当女权主义者开始倡导强奸法律改革时,关于强奸的观念很明确:强奸不是一项需要严肃对待的罪行,因为女性会说谎。经过数十年的刑法改革,法律要求女性必须强烈抵抗男性的性侵犯才能证明自己被强奸这一规定已基本从法典中消失,而且从理论上讲,强奸盾牌法规定女性的既往性史与此无关。然而,尽管法律如此规定,但强奸法律改革并未产生“涓滴效应”,即法律的改变并未带来观念的改变。人们仍然认为女性是报复心强的泼妇,所以警方继续将强奸指控归类为“无根据的”,而检察官也继续选择不起诉许多强奸案件。对许多人来说,“不”有时仍然可能意味着“是”。简而言之,刑法改革在威慑强奸行为和提高强奸定罪率方面仅取得了微不足道的成功。与此同时,刑法改革强化了性别规范,并认可了熟人强奸不太值得严厉惩罚这一观念。本文反对进一步的事后刑法改革,并主张应将努力转向事前的公共卫生干预措施。本文借鉴了公共卫生干预措施在消除艾滋病污名化和使烟草不再被视为正常方面的近期成功经验,并倡导开展一场强有力的公共卫生运动,以使强奸不再被视为正常现象。它提出了一项详细的建议,以改变关于强奸的观念、使强奸不再被视为正常现象,并确保为受害者带来更好的结果。