Gastroenterology Department, University Hospital, Ferrol, Spain.
Gastroenterology Department, Puerta de Hierro University Hospital, Madrid, Spain.
Telemed J E Health. 2020 Jan;26(1):80-88. doi: 10.1089/tmj.2018.0264. Epub 2019 Mar 8.
Mobile apps are useful tools in e-health and self-management strategies in disease monitoring. We evaluated the Harvey-Bradshaw index (HBI) mobile app self-administered by the patient to see if its results agreed with HBI in-clinic assessed by a physician. Patients were enrolled in a 4-month prospective study with clinical assessments at months 1 and 4. Patients completed mobile app HBI and within 48 h, HBI was performed by a physician (gold standard). HBI scores characterized Crohn's disease (CD) as remission <5 or active ≥5. We determined agreement per item and total HBI score and intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). Bland-Altman plot was performed. HBI changes in disease activity from month 1 to month 4 were determined. A total of 219 patients were enrolled. All scheduled assessments (385 pairs of the HBI questionnaire) showed a high percentage of agreement for remission/activity (92.4%, κ = 0.796), positive predictive value (PPV) for remission of 98.2%, and negative predictive value of 76.7%. High agreement was also found at month 1 (93.15%, κ = 0.82) and month 4 (91.5%, κ = 0.75). Bland-Altman plot was more uniform when the HBI mean values were <5 (remission). ICC values were 0.82, 0.897, and 0.879 in all scheduled assessments, 1 and 4 months, respectively. We found a high percentage of agreement between patients' self-administered mobile app HBI and in-clinic physician assessment to detect CD activity with a remarkably high PPV for remission. The mobile app HBI might allow a strict control of inflammation by remote monitoring and flexible follow-up of CD patients. Reduction of sanitary costs could be possible.
移动应用程序是电子健康和疾病监测自我管理策略中的有用工具。我们评估了患者自行管理的 Harvey-Bradshaw 指数 (HBI) 移动应用程序,以确定其结果是否与医生评估的门诊 HBI 相符。患者参加了一项为期 4 个月的前瞻性研究,在第 1 个月和第 4 个月进行临床评估。患者完成移动应用程序 HBI 后,在 48 小时内由医生进行 HBI(金标准)。HBI 评分将克罗恩病 (CD) 分为缓解期(<5)和活动期(≥5)。我们根据每个项目和总 HBI 评分确定了一致性,并计算了组内相关系数 (ICC)。还进行了 Bland-Altman 图分析。确定了从第 1 个月到第 4 个月疾病活动度的 HBI 变化。共有 219 名患者入组。所有预定评估(HBI 问卷 385 对)显示缓解/活动的高百分比一致(92.4%,κ=0.796),缓解的阳性预测值为 98.2%,阴性预测值为 76.7%。在第 1 个月(93.15%,κ=0.82)和第 4 个月(91.5%,κ=0.75)也发现了高度一致。当 HBI 平均值<5(缓解)时,Bland-Altman 图更加均匀。所有预定评估、第 1 个月和第 4 个月的 ICC 值分别为 0.82、0.897 和 0.879。我们发现患者自行管理的移动应用程序 HBI 与医生门诊评估之间存在高百分比的一致性,以检测 CD 活动,缓解的阳性预测值非常高。移动应用程序 HBI 可能通过远程监测和灵活随访 CD 患者来实现对炎症的严格控制。可能会降低卫生成本。