Faculty of Medicine, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Dalhousie Medical School, 5850 College St, Halifax, Nova Scotia, B3H 1X5, Canada.
BMC Med Educ. 2019 Mar 8;19(1):77. doi: 10.1186/s12909-019-1502-5.
The objective of this study was to examine how surgery interest groups (SIGs) across Canada function and influence medical students' interest in surgical careers.
Two unique surveys were distributed using a cross sectional design. The first was sent to SIG executives and the second to SIG members enrolled at a Canadian medical school in the 2016/17 academic year. The prior focused on the types of events hosted, SIG structure/ supports, and barriers/ plans for improvement. The second questionnaire focused on student experience, involvement, and suggestions for improvement.
SIG executives became involved in SIG through classmates and colleagues (8/17, 47%). Their roles focused on organizing events (17/17, 100%), facilitating student contact with resident/surgeons (17/17, 100%), and organizing funding (13/17, 76%). Surgical skills events were among the most successful and well received by students (15/17, 88%). Major barriers faced by SIG executives during their tenure included time conflicts with other interest groups (13/17, 76%), lack of funding (8/17, 47%), and difficulty booking spaces for events (8,17, 47%). SIGs were found to facilitate improvement in basic surgical skills (μ = 3.89/5 ± 0.70) in a comfortable environment (μ = 4.02/5, ±0.6), but were not helpful with final block examinations (μ = 2.98/5, ±0.80). Members indicated that more skills sessions, panel discussion and shadowing opportunities would be beneficial additions. Overall, members felt that SIGs increased their interest in surgical careers (μ = 3.50/5, ±0.79).
Canadian SIGs not only play a critical role in early exposure, but may provide a foundation to contribute to student success in surgery.
本研究旨在探讨加拿大各地的外科兴趣小组(SIG)如何运作以及对医学生对外科职业的兴趣产生影响。
使用横断面设计,分别分发了两份独特的调查问卷。第一份问卷发给 SIG 高管,第二份问卷发给 2016/17 学年在加拿大某所医学院就读的 SIG 成员。前者侧重于举办的活动类型、SIG 结构/支持以及障碍/改进计划。第二份调查问卷侧重于学生的体验、参与情况以及改进建议。
SIG 高管通过同学和同事(8/17,47%)参与 SIG。他们的角色主要集中在组织活动(17/17,100%)、促进学生与住院医师/外科医生的联系(17/17,100%)和组织资金(13/17,76%)。外科技能活动是最成功和最受学生欢迎的活动之一(15/17,88%)。SIG 高管在任期内面临的主要障碍包括与其他兴趣小组的时间冲突(13/17,76%)、缺乏资金(8/17,47%)以及难以预订活动场地(8/17,47%)。SIG 被发现有助于提高基本外科技能(μ=3.89/5±0.70),并在舒适的环境中(μ=4.02/5,±0.6),但对最终块考试没有帮助(μ=2.98/5,±0.80)。成员表示,更多的技能课程、小组讨论和影子机会将是有益的补充。总的来说,成员们认为 SIG 增加了他们对外科职业的兴趣(μ=3.50/5,±0.79)。
加拿大 SIG 不仅在早期接触中发挥了关键作用,而且可能为学生在外科领域的成功做出贡献奠定基础。