Aryal Madhava P, Lee Choonik, Hawkins Peter G, Chapman Christina, Eisbruch Avraham, Mierzwa Michelle, Cao Yue
Departments of Radiation Oncology.
Radiology; and.
Tomography. 2019 Mar;5(1):61-67. doi: 10.18383/j.tom.2018.00029.
Accuracy and precision of quantitative imaging (QI) metrics should be assessed in real time in each patient during a clinical trial to support QI-based decision-making. We developed a framework for real-time quantitative assessment of QI metrics and evaluated accuracy and precision of dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE)-magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-derived blood volume (BV) in a clinical trial for head and neck cancers. Patients underwent DCE-MRI before and after 2 weeks of radiation therapy (2wkRT). A mean as a reference value and a repeatability coefficient (RC) of BV values established from patients in cerebellum volumes of interest (VOIs), which were normal and affected little by therapy, served as accuracy and precision measurements. The BV maps of a new patient were called accurate and precise if the values in cerebellum VOIs and the difference between the 2 scans agreed with the respective mean and RC with 95% confidence. The new data could be used to update reference values. Otherwise, the data were flagged for further evaluation before use in the trial. BV maps from 62 patients enrolled on the trial were evaluated. Mean BV values were 2.21 (±0.14) mL/100 g pre-RT and 2.22 (±0.17) mL/100 g at 2wkRT; relative RC was 15.9%. The BV maps from 3 patients were identified to be inaccurate and imprecise before use in the clinical trial. Our framework of real-time quantitative assessment of QI metrics during a clinical trial can be translated to different QI metrics and organ-sites for supporting QI-based decision-making that warrants success of a clinical trial.
在临床试验期间,应在每位患者中实时评估定量成像(QI)指标的准确性和精密度,以支持基于QI的决策制定。我们开发了一个用于实时定量评估QI指标的框架,并在一项头颈癌临床试验中评估了动态对比增强(DCE)磁共振成像(MRI)衍生的血容量(BV)的准确性和精密度。患者在放射治疗(2wkRT)2周前后接受DCE-MRI检查。以感兴趣的小脑体积(VOIs)中患者建立的BV值的平均值作为参考值,以及重复性系数(RC),这些VOIs正常且受治疗影响较小,用作准确性和精密度测量。如果小脑VOIs中的值以及两次扫描之间的差异在95%置信度下与各自的平均值和RC一致,则新患者的BV图被称为准确和精密的。新数据可用于更新参考值。否则,在试验中使用之前,数据将被标记以供进一步评估。对试验中纳入的62名患者的BV图进行了评估。放疗前平均BV值为2.21(±0.14)mL/100g,2wkRT时为2.22(±0.17)mL/100g;相对RC为15.9%。在临床试验中使用之前,3名患者的BV图被确定为不准确和不精密。我们在临床试验期间对QI指标进行实时定量评估的框架可以转化为不同的QI指标和器官部位,以支持基于QI的决策制定,这保证了临床试验的成功。