Division of Health Policy and Management, School of Public Health, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota.
Center for Surveillance, Epidemiology and Laboratory Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia.
Am J Prev Med. 2019 May;56(5):e153-e161. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2018.10.032. Epub 2019 Mar 16.
Workforce development is one of the ten essential public health services. Recent studies have better characterized individual worker perceptions regarding workforce interests and needs, but gaps remain around workforce needs from program managers' perspectives. This study characterized management perspectives regarding subordinate's abilities and training needs and perceived challenges to recruitment and retention.
In 2017, the Directors Assessment of Workforce Needs Survey was sent to 574 managers at state health agencies across the U.S. Respondents were invited based on the positions they held (i.e., to be included, respondents had to be employed as managers and oversee specific program areas). In 2018, descriptive statistics were calculated, including Fisher's exact for inferential comparisons and Tukey's test for multiple comparisons, as appropriate.
Response rate was 49% after accounting for undeliverable e-mails; 226 respondents met the inclusion criteria. The largest perceived barriers to staff recruitment were wages or salaries (74%) and private sector competition (56%). Similarly, wages or salaries were identified as the main cause of turnover by 70% of respondents, followed by lack of opportunities for advancement (68%), and opportunities outside the agency (67%).
The Directors Assessment of Workforce Needs Survey fills important knowledge gaps and complements previously identified evidence to guide refinement of workforce development efforts. Although competition from the private sector remains challenging, these findings indicate that recruitment and retention must be top priorities in state health agencies nationwide. Prioritizing individual state health agency workforce gaps and committing to provide specific local-level interventions to those priorities is crucial for individual health agencies.
劳动力发展是十大基本公共卫生服务之一。最近的研究更好地描述了个体劳动者对劳动力利益和需求的看法,但从项目管理者的角度来看,劳动力需求仍存在差距。本研究描述了管理者对下属能力和培训需求的看法,以及对招聘和留用的挑战的看法。
2017 年,向美国各州卫生机构的 574 名管理人员发送了“主任评估劳动力需求调查”。根据他们的职位邀请受访者(即,要包括在内,受访者必须担任经理并监督特定的项目领域)。2018 年,计算了描述性统计数据,包括适当情况下的 Fisher 精确检验进行推理比较和 Tukey 检验进行多重比较。
计入无法投递的电子邮件后,回复率为 49%;226 名受访者符合纳入标准。员工招聘的最大障碍是工资或薪水(74%)和私营部门竞争(56%)。同样,70%的受访者认为工资或薪水是离职的主要原因,其次是缺乏晋升机会(68%)和机构外的机会(67%)。
“主任评估劳动力需求调查”填补了重要的知识空白,并补充了以前确定的证据,以指导劳动力发展工作的改进。尽管来自私营部门的竞争仍然具有挑战性,但这些发现表明,招聘和留用必须成为全国各州卫生机构的首要任务。优先考虑各州卫生机构的劳动力差距,并承诺为这些优先事项提供具体的地方一级干预措施,对于各个卫生机构至关重要。