Suppr超能文献

谁在通过 YouTube 提供牙科教育内容?

Who is providing dental education content via YouTube?

机构信息

University of Birmingham/Universidade Federal de Campina Grande, School of Dentistry, Birmingham, UK.

School of Dentistry, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.

出版信息

Br Dent J. 2019 Mar;226(6):437-440. doi: 10.1038/s41415-019-0046-8.

Abstract

Introduction Online video sharing platforms are regularly visited by dental students. However, they may be accessing non-peer-reviewed content which is not officially recommended by their dental school's curriculum.Aims To evaluate the reliability of dental education content found on YouTube.Methods A YouTube search for dental procedures content was conducted using the keywords 'restorative dentistry', 'paediatric dentistry', 'orthodontics' and 'oral surgery'. The first ten results of each search were set according to its publisher. The number of views, length, category, retention index and date of publication were analysed.Results Around 70% of the videos were published under education/science categories. These 40 videos received 25 million visitors and showed an average length of 9.22 min (± 8.19). Universities provided only 5% of the content. Older videos had more views per month (p <0.05) and a better interaction index (p >0.05). Most users preferred the long videos (p <0.05) and the interaction index was better for those older videos (p <0.01). Short videos had 70% user retention, while ten-minute-long videos had 21%.Conclusions Most of the content found did not match the reliability criteria. Universities should consider how their students use YouTube and look to incorporate their findings into their curriculum. Content length and more recent dental videos will influence student retention and learning.

摘要

引言 牙科学生经常访问在线视频分享平台。然而,他们可能会访问未经同行评审的内容,而这些内容并没有被他们所在学校的课程正式推荐。

目的 评估在 YouTube 上找到的牙科教育内容的可靠性。

方法 使用“restorative dentistry”、“paediatric dentistry”、“orthodontics”和“oral surgery”等关键词在 YouTube 上进行了牙科手术内容的搜索。根据出版商设置了每个搜索的前十个结果。分析了观看次数、长度、类别、保留指数和发布日期。

结果 约 70%的视频发布在教育/科学类别下。这 40 个视频的访问量达到了 2500 万,平均长度为 9.22 分钟(±8.19)。大学只提供了 5%的内容。较旧的视频每月的浏览量更多(p<0.05),互动指数更好(p>0.05)。大多数用户更喜欢长视频(p<0.05),而旧视频的互动指数更好(p<0.01)。短视频的用户保留率为 70%,而十分钟长的视频则为 21%。

结论 发现的大部分内容不符合可靠性标准。大学应该考虑学生如何使用 YouTube,并将这些发现纳入他们的课程中。内容长度和更新的牙科视频将影响学生的保留率和学习效果。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验