University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Universidade Federal de Campina Grande, Campina Grande, Brazil.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2022 Nov;26(4):830-837. doi: 10.1111/eje.12766. Epub 2022 Feb 11.
Dental undergraduates will access the Internet searching for learning materials to complement their training; however, open access content is not generally recommended by dental schools. This study aimed to evaluate how dental students are using online video content.
Students from eight Universities (Athens, Birmingham, Brescia, Cardiff, Melbourne, Paris, Sao Paulo and Valdivia) representing three continents were invited to complete a survey on their access and learning from online videos.
International students behave similarly when studying dental content online. Of 515 respondents, 94.6% use the Internet as a learning tool. It was observed that videos are not frequently recommended during didactic lectures (9.6%). But many students (79.9%) will use YouTube for their learning which includes clinical procedures. Students will check online content before performing procedures for the first time (74.8%), to understand what was explained in class (65.9%) or read in books (59.5%), to relearn clinical techniques (64.7%) and to visualise rare procedures (49.8%). More than half of the students do not fully trust the accuracy or the reliability of online content. This does not prevent students from watching and sharing dental videos with classmates (64.4%). The content watched is not shared with teachers (23.3%) even when it contradicts what was learnt in the school (38.2%).
This study concludes that students regularly integrate open access digital resources into learning portfolios but are hesitant to inform their teachers about their viewing habits. Students wish to receive critical skills on how to evaluate the material they encounter outside their traditional learning space.
牙科专业的本科生将通过互联网搜索学习资料来辅助他们的学习,然而开放获取的内容通常不被牙科学校所推荐。本研究旨在评估牙科学生如何使用在线视频内容。
来自八大洲(雅典、伯明翰、布雷西亚、卡迪夫、墨尔本、巴黎、圣保罗和瓦尔迪维亚)的八所大学的学生代表参加了此项研究,他们被邀请完成一份关于在线视频学习的调查。
国际学生在学习牙科内容时表现出相似的行为。在 515 名受访者中,94.6%的学生将互联网作为学习工具。研究观察到,在理论课上视频的推荐频率并不高(9.6%)。但是许多学生(79.9%)会使用 YouTube 来学习,其中包括临床操作。学生在首次操作前会在线查看内容(74.8%),以理解课堂上的讲解(65.9%)或书本上的内容(59.5%),以复习临床技术(64.7%),或观看罕见操作(49.8%)。超过一半的学生对在线内容的准确性和可靠性不完全信任。尽管如此,学生仍会观看并与同学分享牙科视频(64.4%)。学生观看的内容不会与老师分享(23.3%),即使内容与他们在学校所学内容相矛盾(38.2%)。
本研究表明,学生经常将开放获取的数字资源整合到学习档案中,但他们对向老师报告自己的观看习惯犹豫不决。学生希望获得如何评估他们在传统学习环境之外遇到的材料的批判性技能。