International Center for Research on Women, Washington, DC.
International Center for Research on Women, Washington, DC.
J Adolesc Health. 2019 Apr;64(4S):S37-S44. doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2018.12.019. Epub 2019 Mar 20.
Given the importance of developing appropriate measures for assessing social norm change, this article documents the process, results, and lessons learned from a baseline survey measuring social norms related to child marriage in Phalombe and Thyolo districts in Southern Malawi.
A quantitative questionnaire was administered to a representative sample of all adults (age ≥18 years) who self-identified as a decision-maker for at least one girl between the ages of 10 and 17 years, for a total sample size of 1,492 respondents. Measures of empirical expectations, normative expectations, and sanctions related to child marriage were modeled after previously developed measures and social norm theory.
Using an established social norm diagnostic process, this study found that, despite Southern Malawi having the lowest median age of first marriage in the country, child marriage may not be a strong social norm in the intervention communities. Specifically, although 89.3% of respondents expressed the empirical expectation that "Most girls in this community marry before the age of 18," agreement with the normative expectation that "Most people in this community expect girls to marry before the age of 18" was just 53.2% overall and fear of sanctions was just 36.4%.
Taken together, the presence of prudential reasons for child marriage and the weak evidence of normative expectations and sanctions indicate that child marriage may not be a social norm in these communities although it may be indirectly perpetuated by other norms related to adolescent sexuality and access to contraception.
鉴于开发评估社会规范变化的适当措施的重要性,本文记录了在马拉维南部的 Phalombe 和 Thyolo 地区进行的一项基线调查,该调查衡量了与儿童婚姻相关的社会规范,以评估其过程、结果和经验教训。
对所有自认为是 10 至 17 岁女孩的决策者的 18 岁以上成年人(年龄≥18 岁)进行了定量问卷调查,总样本量为 1492 名受访者。与儿童婚姻相关的经验期望、规范期望和制裁措施是在先前开发的措施和社会规范理论的基础上建模的。
通过既定的社会规范诊断过程,本研究发现,尽管马拉维南部的初婚中位数最低,但在干预社区中,儿童婚姻可能不是一个强烈的社会规范。具体而言,尽管 89.3%的受访者表示“本社区大多数女孩在 18 岁之前结婚”的经验期望,但总体上只有 53.2%的受访者同意“本社区大多数人期望女孩在 18 岁之前结婚”的规范期望,只有 36.4%的受访者担心受到制裁。
综上所述,存在为儿童婚姻辩护的谨慎理由,以及规范期望和制裁的证据薄弱,表明在这些社区中,儿童婚姻可能不是一个社会规范,尽管它可能会受到与青少年性行为和获得避孕措施相关的其他规范的间接推动。