New Lucia, Goodridge Donna, Kappel Joanne, Groot Gary, Dobson Roy
College of Medicine Health Sciences Program, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, SK, Canada.
Department of Medicine, College of Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Room 543 Ellis Hall, 108 Hospital Drive, Saskatoon, SK, S7N 0W8, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2019 Mar 28;19(1):199. doi: 10.1186/s12913-019-4014-4.
Frequent hospitalizations and dependency on technology and providers place individuals with chronic kidney disease (CKD) at high risk for multiple safety events. Threats to their safety may be physical, emotional, or psychological. This study sought to explore patient safety from the perspectives and experiences of patients with CKD in acute care settings, and to describe willingness to report incidents utilizing an existing safety reporting system.
This study was conducted using a qualitative interpretive descriptive approach. Face to face interviews were conducted with 30 participants at their bedside during their current hospital admission. The majority of the participants were 50 years or older, of which 75% had a confirmed diagnosis of end stage renal disease with the remainder at stages 3 or 4 of CKD. Eighty percent of the participants were either on hemo- or peritoneal dialysis.
Participants expected to receive safe care, to be taken care of, and to be cared for. Safety threats included: sharing a room with patients who were on precautions; lack of cleanliness; and roommates perceived to be threatening. The concepts of being taken care of and being cared for constituted the safety threats identified within the interpersonal environment. Participants felt taken care of when their physical needs are met and cared for when their psychological and emotional needs are met. There was a general lack of awareness of the presence of a safety reporting system that was to be accessible to patients and families by telephone. There was also an overall unwillingness to report perceived safety incidents, although participants did distinguish between speaking up and reporting.
A key finding was the unwillingness to report incidents using the safety reporting system. Fear of reprisals was the most significant reporting impediment expressed. Actively inviting patients to speak up may be more effective when combined with a psychologically safe environment in order to encourage the involvement of patients in patient safety. System-wide organizational changes may be necessary to mitigate emotional and physical harm for this client population.
慢性肾脏病(CKD)患者频繁住院以及对技术和医护人员的依赖使他们面临多种安全事件的高风险。对其安全的威胁可能是身体、情感或心理方面的。本研究旨在从急性护理环境中CKD患者的观点和经历探索患者安全,并描述使用现有安全报告系统报告事件的意愿。
本研究采用定性解释性描述方法。在30名参与者当前住院期间于其床边进行面对面访谈。大多数参与者年龄在50岁及以上,其中75%确诊为终末期肾病,其余为CKD 3期或4期。80%的参与者接受血液透析或腹膜透析。
参与者期望获得安全护理、得到照顾和关爱。安全威胁包括:与采取预防措施的患者同住一室;缺乏清洁;以及室友被认为具有威胁性。得到照顾和关爱这两个概念构成了人际环境中识别出的安全威胁。当身体需求得到满足时,参与者感到被照顾;当心理和情感需求得到满足时,他们感到被关爱。患者和家属普遍不知道可通过电话使用安全报告系统。尽管参与者确实区分了发声和报告,但总体上不愿意报告察觉到的安全事件。
一个关键发现是不愿意使用安全报告系统报告事件。表达出的最主要报告障碍是害怕报复。积极邀请患者发声,若与心理安全的环境相结合,可能会更有效,以鼓励患者参与患者安全。可能需要全系统的组织变革来减轻这一患者群体所遭受的情感和身体伤害。