Ayanniyi Olusola, Egwu Roseline F, Adeniyi Ade F
Department of Physiotherapy, College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria.
Orthopaedic Unit, Barau Dikko Specialist Hospital, Kaduna, Nigeria.
Hong Kong Physiother J. 2016 Oct 26;36:1-9. doi: 10.1016/j.hkpj.2016.07.002. eCollection 2017 Jun.
knee osteoarthritis (OA) is a prevalent condition. Little is known about whether treatments provided by physiotherapists to patients with knee OA in Nigeria follow recommended clinical practice guidelines.
The aims of this study were to investigate Nigerian physiotherapists' treatment preferences for knee osteoarthritis (OA) and to evaluate if their preferences were in line with contemporary clinical practice guidelines and recommendations.
A cross-sectional survey of 267 physiotherapists from various health institutions in Nigeria were surveyed, using a structured questionnaire incorporating a clinical vignette on knee OA.
Based on the clinical vignette, the majority of the respondents (68.2%) recommended review of x-rays as part of the diagnostic process for knee OA. Thermotherapy was the most utilized modality (86.1%), followed by therapeutic exercise (81.3%). Only 11.1% of the physiotherapists used therapeutic exercise alone. Manual therapy in conjunction with other modalities was the choice for 18% of the physiotherapists. Only 49.1% of the physiotherapists reported including advice on weight control and up to 39% reported bed rest as part of the treatment approach.
There was a poor consensus among the physiotherapists in Nigeria on how knee OA is managed compared with contemporary clinical guidelines and recommendations which emphasized application of core modalities, such as therapeutic exercises, patients' education, and weight control over passive modalities. Some areas of practice are in line with contemporary guidelines, while some were in conflict with evidence-based practice.
膝关节骨关节炎(OA)是一种常见病症。关于尼日利亚物理治疗师为膝关节OA患者提供的治疗是否遵循推荐的临床实践指南,人们知之甚少。
本研究旨在调查尼日利亚物理治疗师对膝关节骨关节炎(OA)的治疗偏好,并评估他们的偏好是否符合当代临床实践指南和建议。
采用结构化问卷对尼日利亚各卫生机构的267名物理治疗师进行横断面调查,问卷包含一个关于膝关节OA的临床案例。
根据临床案例,大多数受访者(68.2%)建议将X线检查作为膝关节OA诊断过程的一部分。热疗是最常用的治疗方式(86.1%),其次是治疗性运动(81.3%)。只有11.1%的物理治疗师仅使用治疗性运动。18%的物理治疗师选择手法治疗与其他方式结合使用。只有49.1%的物理治疗师报告在治疗方法中包括体重控制建议,高达39%的物理治疗师报告将卧床休息作为治疗方法的一部分。
与强调应用核心方式(如治疗性运动、患者教育和体重控制)而非被动方式的当代临床指南和建议相比,尼日利亚的物理治疗师在膝关节OA的管理方面缺乏共识。一些实践领域符合当代指南,而一些则与循证实践相冲突。