Goudie Christine, Gill Atamjit, Shanahan Jessica, Furey Andrew, Dubrowski Adam
Medical Education and Simulation, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, CAN.
Obstetrics and Gynecology, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John's, CAN.
Cureus. 2019 Jan 31;11(1):e3991. doi: 10.7759/cureus.3991.
Advancing global healthcare in developing countries has traditionally been an area of interest for many North American medical organizations, as they strive to improve patient outcomes by helping to control disease and death-related illnesses. Women's healthcare in developing countries, in particular, presents a unique set of complexities, revealing high maternal mortality statistics surrounding pregnancy, labor, and childbirth, which is often tied to home births without medically trained attendants. In September 2018, Team Broken Earth, a Canadian-based outreach initiative, hosted a three-day women's healthcare course in Dhaka, Bangladesh, which included simulation-based training stations, for the purpose of advancing clinical skills and education in regards to local labor and delivery. The training stations included the prevention of shoulder dystocia, helping babies breathe, the application of uterine compression sutures, and the repair of obstetric anal sphincter injuries (OASIS). The OASIS management station provided an opportunity to practice anal sphincter repair on anatomically accurate silicone models, which was a focus of the training course due to the high frequency of such injuries in rural Bangladesh. Evaluation surveys were supplied to workshop participants to capture their feedback about the use of the OASIS models and their efficacy as a training tool in Bangladesh. Overall, the models were considered superior as compared to pre-existing training methods, which traditionally involve textbook education and hands-on learning in emergency birthing scenarios by non-medically trained attendants. Two minor iterative improvements were suggested during the Team Broken Earth workshops in Dhaka, Bangladesh, with regards to improving the models for future use: (a) the ethnicity coloring of the models should be more inclusive, especially when delivering training in international countries, and (b) future silicone models should include the addition of mesh across the bottom layer to ensure participants fingers did not rupture the enclosed vaginal canal while suturing. The purpose of this technical report is to determine the efficacy of a silicone OASIS model, developed for practicing high-risk laceration repair that can occur during childbirth, which presents in higher frequency in developing countries, such as Bangladesh, due to the number of rural at-home deliveries. The original study in this series involved the investigation of silicone perineal repair models focusing on first- and second-degree lacerations, which were used at the Remote and Rural Conference in St. John's, Newfoundland, in April 2018. The facilitators distributed the first iteration of the models to conference participants and collected participant feedback, which concluded that several improvements were required to enhance the models for medical training purposes. With the iterative revisions complete, the model is now under further validation testing to determine its efficacy within simulation-based medical education (SBME) and clinical skill maintenance. This technical report is the second in the series and includes the most recent third and fourth-degree silicone models as well as all suggested improvements from previous clinical feedback.
在发展中国家推进全球医疗保健一直是许多北美医疗组织感兴趣的领域,因为它们致力于通过帮助控制疾病和与死亡相关的疾病来改善患者的治疗效果。特别是发展中国家的妇女医疗保健存在一系列独特的复杂性,显示出围绕怀孕、分娩和生产的孕产妇死亡率很高,这往往与没有经过医学培训的护理人员在家中分娩有关。2018年9月,总部位于加拿大的外展倡议组织“破碎地球团队”在孟加拉国达卡举办了为期三天的妇女医疗保健课程,其中包括基于模拟的培训站,目的是提高当地分娩和接生方面的临床技能和教育水平。培训站包括预防肩难产、帮助婴儿呼吸、应用子宫压迫缝合以及修复产科肛门括约肌损伤(OASIS)。OASIS管理站提供了在解剖学上精确的硅胶模型上练习肛门括约肌修复的机会,由于孟加拉国农村地区此类损伤的发生率很高,这是培训课程的一个重点。向研讨会参与者提供了评估调查问卷,以收集他们对OASIS模型的使用情况及其作为孟加拉国培训工具的效果的反馈。总体而言,与传统的培训方法相比,这些模型被认为更优越,传统方法通常包括教科书教育以及由未经医学培训的护理人员在紧急分娩场景中进行实践学习。在孟加拉国达卡的“破碎地球团队”研讨会上,就改进模型以供未来使用提出了两项小的迭代改进建议:(a)模型的种族肤色应更具包容性,特别是在国际国家进行培训时;(b)未来的硅胶模型应在底层添加网眼,以确保参与者在缝合时手指不会弄破封闭的阴道管。本技术报告的目的是确定一种硅胶OASIS模型的效果,该模型是为练习分娩期间可能发生的高风险撕裂伤修复而开发的,由于孟加拉国等发展中国家农村家庭分娩的数量众多,这种撕裂伤在这些国家更为常见。本系列的原始研究涉及对专注于一度和二度撕裂伤的硅胶会阴修复模型的调查,这些模型于2018年4月在纽芬兰圣约翰斯的偏远和农村会议上使用。主持人将模型的第一版分发给会议参与者并收集参与者的反馈,结果表明需要进行一些改进以提高模型用于医学培训的目的。随着迭代修订完成,该模型现在正在进行进一步的验证测试,以确定其在基于模拟的医学教育(SBME)和临床技能维持中的效果。本技术报告是该系列中的第二篇,包括最新的三度和四度硅胶模型以及先前临床反馈中提出的所有改进建议。