Norii Tatsuya, Kimura Nobuhiko, Homma Yosuke, Funakoshi Hiraku, Crandall Cameron
Department of Emergency Medicine University of New Mexico Albuquerque New Mexico.
Department of Emergency and Critical Care Medicine Tokyo Bay Urayasu Ichikawa Medical Center Urayasu-city Chiba Japan.
Acute Med Surg. 2018 Dec 27;6(2):109-116. doi: 10.1002/ams2.384. eCollection 2019 Apr.
Worldwide, health-care providers carry out procedural sedation and analgesia (PSA) in the emergency department. However, training opportunities are limited in many Asian countries, including Japan. We formed an educational group consisting of board-certified emergency physicians in the USA and Japanese physicians and developed a PSA training module. The aims of our study were to demonstrate the effectiveness of training and to describe PSA practice in Japan.
We undertook a pretest of PSA knowledge questions and a retest immediately after the training intervention. We also carried out a survey and asked about participants' PSA practice. The training module consisted of four didactic hours and three simulation and skills laboratory hours. Results of all pre- and post-intervention knowledge questions were analyzed with McNemar's test, and overall scores were analyzed with a paired -test.
One hundred and forty-four health-care providers including 123 physicians, 16 nurses, two pharmacists, and three medical students participated in the training. A total of 119 (83%) completed both the pre- and post-intervention knowledge questions. Before the training, participants scored an average 66% (63%-69%) on the written knowledge test. After the intervention, participants showed significant improvement on the knowledge test (improvement 17%; 14%-20%). Among participants who answered the practice survey, 121 (88%) have undertaken PSA. Only 14 (12%) participants always or often use a continuous capnography for PSA. Only 32 (26.4%) participants undertook pre-PSA systematic evaluation.
Our educational intervention successfully increased participants' knowledge. Only the minority of health-care providers use capnography routinely for PSA, and pre-PSA evaluation is not commonly carried out.
在全球范围内,医疗保健提供者在急诊科实施程序性镇静和镇痛(PSA)。然而,在包括日本在内的许多亚洲国家,培训机会有限。我们组建了一个由美国的董事会认证急诊医师和日本医师组成的教育小组,并开发了一个PSA培训模块。我们研究的目的是证明培训的有效性,并描述日本的PSA实践情况。
我们在培训干预前进行了PSA知识问题的预测试,并在培训干预后立即进行了重新测试。我们还开展了一项调查,询问参与者的PSA实践情况。培训模块包括四个授课小时和三个模拟及技能实验室小时。干预前后所有知识问题的结果用McNemar检验进行分析,总体得分用配对t检验进行分析。
144名医疗保健提供者参与了培训,其中包括123名医生、16名护士、2名药剂师和3名医科学生。共有119人(83%)完成了干预前后的知识问题测试。培训前,参与者在书面知识测试中的平均得分为66%(63%-69%)。干预后,参与者在知识测试中表现出显著提高(提高了17%;14%-20%)。在回答实践调查的参与者中,121人(88%)进行过PSA。只有14人(12%)的参与者在PSA时总是或经常使用持续二氧化碳监测。只有32人(26.4%)的参与者进行了PSA前的系统评估。
我们的教育干预成功提高了参与者的知识水平。只有少数医疗保健提供者在PSA时常规使用二氧化碳监测,并且PSA前评估并不普遍开展。