Department of Anesthesiology & Institute for Informatics, School of Medicine, Washington University in St Louis, St. Louis, MO, United States.
Division of Epidemiology & Biostatistics, School of Public Health, University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL, United States.
J Biomed Inform. 2019 Jun;94:103178. doi: 10.1016/j.jbi.2019.103178. Epub 2019 Apr 16.
Prior research has used a variety of qualitative and quantitative approaches for studying handoff communication. Due to the dynamic and interactive nature of handoffs, characterizing the structure and content of these conversations is challenging. In this paper, we use a graph-based approach to characterize handoff communication as a conversation network. Conversation networks were used to compare the structural properties of resident-resident and nurse-nurse handoff communication. Resident (n = 149) and nurse (n = 126) handoff conversations from general medicine units were coded using a previously validated clinical content framework. The coded conversations were then translated into separate resident and nurse conversation networks, and were compared using 11 network measures. Transition probabilities were used to identify commonly repeating sub-networks within resident and nurse conversations. There were significant differences between resident and nurse conversation networks in 10 of the 11 network measures. There were also significant differences in the structure of conversations: compared to resident conversations, nurse conversations were focused on fewer clinical content categories and had more branching and switching between clinical content categories; however, there were clinically-relevant organic relationships in the order of presentation of clinical content among both resident and nurse handoff conversations. We discuss the potential for using graph-based approach as an alternative method for characterizing interactive conversations and also suggest future directions for using network-based approaches for analyzing handoff conversations.
先前的研究已经使用了各种定性和定量方法来研究交接沟通。由于交接的动态和交互性质,描述这些对话的结构和内容具有挑战性。在本文中,我们使用基于图的方法将交接沟通描述为对话网络。使用对话网络来比较住院医生-住院医生和护士-护士交接沟通的结构特性。使用先前验证的临床内容框架对来自普通内科病房的住院医生(n=149)和护士(n=126)的交接对话进行编码。然后,将编码的对话转换为单独的住院医生和护士对话网络,并使用 11 种网络度量进行比较。转移概率用于识别住院医生和护士对话中常见的重复子网络。在 11 种网络度量中的 10 种中,住院医生和护士对话网络存在显著差异。在对话的结构上也存在显著差异:与住院医生的对话相比,护士的对话集中在较少的临床内容类别上,并且在临床内容类别之间有更多的分支和切换;然而,在住院医生和护士交接对话中,临床内容的呈现顺序存在与临床相关的有机关系。我们讨论了使用基于图的方法作为描述交互对话的替代方法的潜力,并提出了使用基于网络的方法分析交接对话的未来方向。