Radical pair intersystem crossing: Quantum dynamics or incoherent kinetics?

Magnetic field effects on radical pair reactions arise due to the interplay of coherent electron spin dynamics and spin relaxation effects, a rigorous treatment of which requires the solution of the Liouville-von Neumann equation. However, it is often found that simple incoherent kinetic models of the radical pair singlet-triplet intersystem crossing provide an acceptable description of experimental measurements. In this paper, we outline the theoretical basis for this incoherent kinetic description, elucidating its connection to exact quantum mechanics. We show, in particular, how the finite lifetime of the radical pair spin states, as well as any additional spin-state dephasing, leads to incoherent intersystem crossing. We arrive at simple expressions for the radical pair spin state interconversion rates to which the functional form proposed recently by Steiner et al. [J. Phys. Chem. C 122, 11701 (2018)] can be regarded as an approximation. We also test the kinetic master equation against exact quantum dynamical simulations for a model radical pair and for a series of PTZ-Ph-PDI molecular wires.