Rhodes Ramona L, Ukoha Nkemdirim C E, Williams Kimberly A, Elwood Bryan, Knox-Rice Tori, Lee Simon C, Tiro Jasmin A, Skinner Celette Sugg, Halm Ethan A
1 Division of Geriatric Medicine, UT Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX, USA.
2 Harold C. Simmons Comprehensive Cancer Center, UT Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, TX, USA.
Am J Hosp Palliat Care. 2019 Dec;36(12):1057-1062. doi: 10.1177/1049909119843276. Epub 2019 Apr 21.
Advance care planning (ACP), palliative care (PC), and hospice are often underutilized by African Americans (AAs). This study assessed the impact of stage of intent to discuss ACP options as key potential barriers.
We examined intent to discuss completion of ACP, PC, and hospice among 22 AA patients with cancer admitted to a local safety net hospital. Participants were asked about intent to discuss an advanced directive or living will (AD/LW), medical power of attorney (MPOA), PC, and hospice with their doctors. Intent to discuss these ACP components was based on the transtheoretical model. Electronic health records were reviewed at various intervals to assess completion of ACP behaviors and survival.
Participants had colorectal (33%), breast (44%), and lung (23%) cancer, and 82% had stage III/IV disease. Low percentages of patients were in the precontemplation stage for AD/LW completion (4.6%), MPOA completion (13.6%), and PC discussions (27.2%), but 77.2% were in the precontemplation stage for hospice discussions. At 1 year, only 5% completed an AD/LW, 36.4% appointed an MPOA, 42.9% were referred to PC, and 12.5% were referred to hospice. More than half (54.6%) were deceased by the study's conclusion. Most (81%) of these died within 6 months of their baseline study assessment.
Despite being hospitalized with advanced cancer and having poor prognosis, intent to discuss ACP options, PC, and hospice in this population was variable, and completion of these activities was low. This formative research is needed to develop education and counseling interventions for this high-risk, vulnerable population.
非裔美国人(AA)对预先护理计划(ACP)、姑息治疗(PC)和临终关怀的利用率往往较低。本研究评估了作为关键潜在障碍的讨论ACP选项的意向阶段的影响。
我们调查了当地一家安全网医院收治的22名患有癌症的非裔美国患者讨论完成ACP、PC和临终关怀的意向。参与者被问及是否打算与医生讨论预先指示或生前遗嘱(AD/LW)、医疗委托书(MPOA)、PC和临终关怀。讨论这些ACP组成部分的意向基于跨理论模型。在不同时间间隔审查电子健康记录,以评估ACP行为的完成情况和生存率。
参与者患有结直肠癌(33%)、乳腺癌(44%)和肺癌(23%),82%患有III/IV期疾病。处于AD/LW完成前思考阶段的患者比例较低(4.6%),MPOA完成前思考阶段的患者比例为13.6%,PC讨论前思考阶段的患者比例为27.2%,但77.2%的患者处于临终关怀讨论前思考阶段。1年后,只有5%的人完成了AD/LW,36.4%的人指定了MPOA,42.9%的人被转介接受PC,12.5%的人被转介接受临终关怀。到研究结束时,超过一半(54.6%)的人死亡。其中大多数(81%)在基线研究评估后的6个月内死亡。
尽管因晚期癌症住院且预后不良,但该人群讨论ACP选项、PC和临终关怀的意向各不相同,这些活动的完成率较低。需要进行这项形成性研究,为这一高风险、易受伤害的人群制定教育和咨询干预措施。