Kiberu Vincent Micheal, Scott Richard E, Mars Maurice
Department of TeleHealth, Nelson R. Mandela School of Medicine, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa.
NT Consulting - Global e-Health Inc, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2019 Apr 29;19(1):266. doi: 10.1186/s12913-019-4057-6.
In developing countries like Uganda, there are shortages of health workers especially medical specialists. The referral process is frustrating to both patients and health workers (HWs). This is due to delays in accessing laboratory results/tests, costs of travel with resultant delay in consulting specialists. Telemedicine can help reduce these problems. To facilitate successful and sustainable telemedicine implementation the eHealth readiness of different stakeholders should be undertaken. This study was conducted at public health facilities (HFs) in Uganda to assess eHealth readiness across four domains; core, e-learning, clinical and technology, that might hamper adoption and integration of telemedicine.
A cross-sectional study using mixed methods for data collection was conducted at health center IVs, regional and national referral hospitals. The study was conducted in three parts. Quantitative data on core, e-learning and clinical readiness domains were collected from doctors and other healthcare providers (nurses/midwives, public health officers and allied healthcare workers). Respondents were categorised into 'aware and used telemedicine', 'aware and not used', 'unaware of telemedicine'. Focus Group Discussions were conducted with patients to further assess core readiness. Technology readiness was assessed using a questionnaire with purposively selected respondents; directors, heads of medical sections, and hospital managers/superintendents. Descriptive statistics and correlations were performed using Spearman's rank order test for relationship between technology readiness variables at the HFs.
70% of health professionals surveyed across three levels of HF were aware of telemedicine and 41% had used telemedicine. However, over 40% of HWs at HC-IV and RRH were unaware of telemedicine. All doctors who had used telemedicine were impressed with it. Telemedicine users and non-users who were aware of telemedicine showed core, clinical, and learning readiness. Patients were aware of telemedicine but identified barriers to its use. A weak but positive correlation existed between the different variables in technology readiness.
Respondents who were aware of and used telemedicine across all HF levels indicated core, learning and clinical readiness for adoption and integration of telemedicine at the public HFs in Uganda, although patients noted potential barriers that might need attention. In terms of technology readiness, gaps still exit at the various HF levels.
在乌干达等发展中国家,卫生工作者尤其是医学专家短缺。转诊过程让患者和卫生工作者都感到沮丧。这是由于获取实验室结果/检查存在延迟,以及出行成本导致咨询专家的延迟。远程医疗有助于减少这些问题。为促进远程医疗的成功和可持续实施,应评估不同利益相关者的电子健康就绪情况。本研究在乌干达的公共卫生机构进行,以评估可能阻碍远程医疗采用和整合的四个领域(核心、电子学习、临床和技术)的电子健康就绪情况。
在四级卫生中心、区域和国家转诊医院进行了一项采用混合方法收集数据的横断面研究。该研究分三个部分进行。从医生和其他医疗保健提供者(护士/助产士、公共卫生官员和相关医疗工作者)收集关于核心、电子学习和临床就绪领域的定量数据。受访者被分为“知晓并使用远程医疗”、“知晓但未使用”、“不知晓远程医疗”三类。与患者进行焦点小组讨论以进一步评估核心就绪情况。使用问卷对有目的地挑选的受访者(主任、医疗科室负责人和医院经理/院长)进行技术就绪情况评估。使用Spearman等级顺序检验对卫生机构技术就绪变量之间的关系进行描述性统计和相关性分析。
在三个级别的卫生机构接受调查的卫生专业人员中,70%知晓远程医疗,41%使用过远程医疗。然而,四级卫生中心和区域转诊医院超过40%的卫生工作者不知晓远程医疗。所有使用过远程医疗的医生都对其印象深刻。知晓远程医疗的远程医疗使用者和非使用者表现出核心、临床和学习方面的就绪情况。患者知晓远程医疗,但指出了其使用的障碍。技术就绪的不同变量之间存在微弱但积极的相关性。
在所有卫生机构级别中知晓并使用远程医疗的受访者表明,乌干达公共卫生机构在采用和整合远程医疗方面具备核心、学习和临床就绪情况,尽管患者指出了可能需要关注的潜在障碍。在技术就绪方面,各级卫生机构仍然存在差距。