Blanck Paul, Stoffel Martin, Bents Hinrich, Ditzen Beate, Mander Johannes
Center for Psychological Psychotherapy, and.
Institute of Medical Psychology, Center for Psychosocial Medicine, University of Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany.
J Nerv Ment Dis. 2019 Jun;207(6):451-458. doi: 10.1097/NMD.0000000000000994.
Heart rate variability (HRV) can be conceptualized as a marker of an individual's capability to adaptively respond to its environment and has been linked with mental health. Although conceptually and empirically linked to social behavior and thus relevant in the therapeutic setting, HRV is seldom investigated directly within therapy sessions. In the present examination, we aimed at addressing this research gap by assessing patients' and therapists' HRVs both ambulatory within therapy sessions and under resting conditions. Drawing on polyvagal theory, we hypothesized that higher in-session HRV is accompanied with higher therapeutic alliance ratings. Further, we expected baseline HRV to predict symptomatic outcome and to increase over the course of therapy. In a sample of 53 outpatients receiving 25 sessions of cognitive behavioral therapy, we measured HRV, therapeutic alliance and depressive symptoms on four occasions. Multilevel modeling analyses demonstrated that patients with higher in-session high-frequency HRV rated the therapeutic alliance higher. Baseline HRV predicted symptomatic outcome and increased over the course of therapy. Possible explanations involve a link between in-session HRV and in-session behavior and should be investigated in future studies. The results highlight the usefulness of in-session HRV as a promising process variable in psychotherapy research.
心率变异性(HRV)可被视为个体对环境进行适应性反应能力的一个指标,并且一直与心理健康相关联。尽管在概念和实证上与社会行为相关,因此在治疗环境中具有相关性,但HRV在治疗过程中很少被直接研究。在本次研究中,我们旨在通过评估患者和治疗师在治疗过程中及静息状态下的动态HRV来填补这一研究空白。基于多元迷走神经理论,我们假设治疗过程中较高的HRV与较高的治疗联盟评分相关。此外,我们预期基线HRV能够预测症状改善结果,并在治疗过程中升高。在一个包含53名接受25次认知行为治疗的门诊患者的样本中,我们在四个时间点测量了HRV、治疗联盟和抑郁症状。多层次建模分析表明,治疗过程中高频HRV较高的患者对治疗联盟的评分更高。基线HRV预测了症状改善结果,并在治疗过程中升高。可能的解释涉及治疗过程中HRV与治疗过程中行为之间的联系,这一点应在未来的研究中进行调查。结果突出了治疗过程中HRV作为心理治疗研究中一个有前景的过程变量的有用性。