Xiao Chao, Jiang Yanwei, Liang Man
Department of Forensic Medicine, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, 13 Hangkong Road, Wuhan 430030, China.
Institute of Forensic Science, Tianjin Public Security Bureau, 4 Baoding Road, Tianjin 300193, China.
Forensic Sci Int. 2019 Jul;300:e13-e19. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2019.04.022. Epub 2019 Apr 27.
In the present case, due to the lack of database matches and available relatives, the use of single-source DNA profiles from the unidentified deceased and the suspect was not yet able to determine the identity of them, resulting in the inability to continue the investigation. However, by interpreting a simple mixture on the penile swab of the deceased and a complex mixture on the prayer flag wrapped around the ankles of the deceased, the information embedded in these two mixtures provided us with a breakthrough point for addressing the identity determination. Preliminary analysis using the separating method or based on imbalanced peaks at the Amelogenin locus revealed that each of the two DNA mixtures should have a female minor contributor, who were likely to be sex workers according to the investigation results. Consequently, blood samples from fifty-two women were collected for STR genotyping. The analysis results of the two mixtures using LRmix Studio showed that the probability of the simple mixture that if it came from the deceased and the female numbered P0053 is 4.7078 × 10 times more likely than if it came from the deceased and an unknown female, while the probability of the complex mixture that if it came from P0062, the deceased and the male suspect is 8.1777 × 10 times more likely than if it came from the deceased and two unknowns. Subsequently, based on the clues provided by P0053 and P0062, the identity of the deceased and the suspect was successfully determined and the case was finally resolved. These results suggest the valuable evidence that can be obtained from mixtures and the high priority that should be placed on the analysis of mixtures, especially those that may be considered unlikely to derive complete single-source profiles by interpretation. In addition, the occurrence of a secondary DNA transfer was confirmed.
在本案中,由于缺乏数据库匹配信息且无可供利用的亲属,利用来自身份不明死者和嫌疑人的单源DNA图谱尚无法确定他们的身份,导致调查无法继续进行。然而,通过解读死者阴茎拭子上的简单混合图谱以及包裹在死者脚踝处经幡上的复杂混合图谱,这两种混合图谱中蕴含的信息为我们解决身份认定问题提供了一个突破点。使用分离方法或基于牙釉蛋白基因座处不平衡峰进行的初步分析表明,这两种DNA混合图谱中均应有一名女性次要贡献者,根据调查结果,她们很可能是性工作者。因此,收集了52名女性的血样进行STR基因分型。使用LRmix Studio对这两种混合图谱的分析结果显示,简单混合图谱若来自死者和编号为P0053的女性,其可能性比来自死者和一名未知女性的可能性高4.7078×10倍,而复杂混合图谱若来自P0062、死者和男性嫌疑人,其可能性比来自死者和两名未知人员的可能性高8.1777×10倍。随后,根据P0053和P0062提供的线索,成功确定了死者和嫌疑人的身份,案件最终得以侦破。这些结果表明,可从混合图谱中获取有价值的证据,并且应高度重视对混合图谱的分析,尤其是那些可能被认为不太可能通过解读得出完整单源图谱的混合图谱。此外,还证实了二次DNA转移的发生。