1 Medical Services Division, Public Health Branch, California Correctional Health Care Services, Elk Grove, CA, USA.
Public Health Rep. 2019 May/Jun;134(1_suppl):71S-79S. doi: 10.1177/0033354919826557.
In California, about 80% of tuberculosis disease is caused by untreated latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI), and the rate of LTBI is higher among incarcerated persons (16%) than among nonincarcerated persons (6%). We compared 2 regimens to treat LTBI in an adult prison population in California: 9 months of twice-weekly isoniazid (9H; previous standard of care) and 12 once-weekly doses of isoniazid and rifapentine (3HP; introduced in 2011).
We evaluated the rates of completion and discontinuation caused by hepatotoxicity among randomly selected patients with LTBI prescribed the 9H regimen in 2011 and among patients with LTBI prescribed the 3HP regimen who entered California prisons during September 2013-March 2014. We compared the cost per fully treated patient for the 2 regimens.
Of 92 patients treated with the 9H regimen, the treatment completion rate was 42% and discontinuation due to hepatotoxicity was 14%. Of 122 patients who accepted the 3HP regimen, the completion rate was 90% and discontinuation due to hepatotoxicity was 2%. The cost per fully treated patient for the 9H regimen was $981 and for 3HP was $652.
In an incarcerated population, the 3HP regimen had a higher completion rate, lower hepatotoxicity, and lower cost per fully treated patient than the 9H regimen. If coupled with a high treatment initiation rate, the high rate of LTBI treatment completion with 3HP may contribute to reducing tuberculosis morbidity in California.
在加利福尼亚州,约 80%的结核病是由未经治疗的潜伏性结核感染(LTBI)引起的,而在被监禁者(16%)中的 LTBI 发生率高于非被监禁者(6%)。我们比较了加利福尼亚州成人监狱人群中两种治疗 LTBI 的方案:9 个月每周两次异烟肼(9H;既往标准治疗)和 12 个月每周一次异烟肼和利福平(3HP;2011 年引入)。
我们评估了在 2011 年随机选择的接受 9H 方案治疗的 LTBI 患者和在 2013 年 9 月至 2014 年 3 月期间进入加利福尼亚监狱的接受 3HP 方案治疗的 LTBI 患者中,因肝毒性导致的完成率和停药率。我们比较了两种方案的每位完全治疗患者的成本。
92 名接受 9H 方案治疗的患者中,治疗完成率为 42%,因肝毒性导致的停药率为 14%。122 名接受 3HP 方案治疗的患者中,完成率为 90%,因肝毒性导致的停药率为 2%。9H 方案每位完全治疗患者的成本为 981 美元,3HP 方案为 652 美元。
在被监禁人群中,3HP 方案的完成率更高,肝毒性更低,每位完全治疗患者的成本更低,优于 9H 方案。如果与高治疗启动率相结合,3HP 方案高的 LTBI 治疗完成率可能有助于减少加利福尼亚州的结核病发病率。