School of Health Sciences, College of Education, Health and Human Development, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand.
Lojic Institute, CS Group, New South Wales, Australia.
Sleep Med Rev. 2019 Aug;46:54-63. doi: 10.1016/j.smrv.2019.04.004. Epub 2019 Apr 6.
Sleep problems are prevalent in people with rare genetic neurodevelopmental disorders (RGND) and, in some cases, RGNDs are associated with specific forms of sleep disturbance that appear relatively unique. Although a notable amount of research has focused on behavioral intervention for sleep problems in people with higher incidence developmental disorders, research focused on potentially modifiable learning and environmental factors for people with RGND has received less attention. This review summarizes empirical evidence from studies providing behavioral interventions for sleep problems in RGND. A systematic search identified nine studies for inclusion. Studies were coded to extract data on participant characteristics, intervention components, dependent variables, research rigor and intervention effects. Study rigor was then evaluated using an established criteria and effects were classified as positive, neutral or mixed. Seven of the nine studies demonstrated positive treatment effects and two mixed results. In most studies, treatment consisted of multiple intervention components and were implemented by parents in the home. However, only three studies met criteria for an adequate level of rigor, thus greatly limiting certainty of conclusions. This review identifies current intervention practices and potential foci for future research.
睡眠问题在患有罕见遗传性神经发育障碍(RGND)的人群中很普遍,在某些情况下,RGND 与特定形式的睡眠障碍有关,这些障碍似乎相对独特。尽管大量研究集中在针对具有较高发病率发育障碍人群的睡眠问题的行为干预上,但针对 RGND 人群的潜在可改变的学习和环境因素的研究受到的关注较少。本综述总结了为 RGND 人群提供睡眠问题行为干预的研究的实证证据。系统搜索确定了九项纳入的研究。对研究进行编码以提取参与者特征、干预成分、因变量、研究严谨性和干预效果的数据。然后使用既定标准评估研究的严谨性,并将效果分类为阳性、中性或混合。九项研究中有七项显示出积极的治疗效果,两项混合结果。在大多数研究中,治疗包括多种干预成分,并由父母在家中实施。然而,只有三项研究符合足够严谨性的标准,因此极大地限制了结论的确定性。本综述确定了当前的干预实践和未来研究的潜在重点。