Department of Infectious Diseases and Hospital Epidemiology, University Hospital Zürich, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
VA Ann Arbor Healthcare System, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
BMJ Open. 2019 May 9;9(5):e026009. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-026009.
We explored patient perceptions regarding physician attire in different clinical contexts and resultant effects on the physician-patient relationship.
The 900-bed University Hospital Zurich, Switzerland.
A convenience sample of patients receiving care in dermatology, infectious diseases and neurology ambulatory clinics of the University Hospital Zurich participated in a paper-based survey.
The survey instrument was randomised and showed photographs of male or female physicians wearing various forms of attire. On the basis of the respondents' ratings of how the physician's attire affected perceptions across five domains (knowledgeable, trustworthy, caring, approachable and comfort with the physician), a composite preference score for attire was calculated as the primary outcome. Secondary outcomes included variation in preferences by respondent characteristics and context in which care was provided.
Of 834 patient respondents (140 in dermatology, 422 in infectious diseases and 272 in neurology), 298 (36%) agreed that physician attire was important. When compared with all available choices, the combination of white scrubs with white coat was rated highest while a business suit ranked lowest. Variation in preferences and opinions for attire were noted relative to respondent demographics and the clinical setting in which the survey was administered. For example, compared with younger patients, respondents ≥65 years of age more often reported that physician dress was both important to them and influenced how happy they were with their care (p=0.047 and p=0.001, respectively).
Outpatients at a large Swiss University hospital prefer their physicians to be dressed in white scrubs with white coat. Substantial variation among respondents based on demographics, type of physician and clinical setting were observed. Healthcare systems should consider context of care when defining policies related to dress code.
我们探讨了患者在不同临床环境下对医生着装的看法,以及这对医患关系的影响。
瑞士苏黎世大学附属医院,900 张病床。
苏黎世大学附属医院皮肤科、传染病科和神经科门诊就诊的方便样本患者参加了纸质问卷调查。
调查工具是随机的,展示了男性或女性医生穿着不同形式着装的照片。根据受访者对医生着装在五个方面(知识渊博、值得信赖、关怀、平易近人和对医生的舒适感)的评价,计算出着装的综合偏好评分作为主要结果。次要结果包括按受访者特征和提供护理的环境的偏好差异。
在 834 名患者受访者中(皮肤科 140 名,传染病科 422 名,神经科 272 名),有 298 名(36%)同意医生着装很重要。与所有可用选择相比,白色工作服搭配白色外套的组合评分最高,而西装套装的评分最低。相对于受访者的人口统计学特征和进行调查的临床环境,着装的偏好和意见存在差异。例如,与年轻患者相比,≥65 岁的患者更经常报告说医生的着装对他们很重要,并影响他们对护理的满意度(p=0.047 和 p=0.001)。
瑞士一家大型大学附属医院的门诊患者希望他们的医生穿白色工作服配白色外套。根据人口统计学、医生类型和临床环境的不同,受访者之间存在很大差异。医疗保健系统在制定与着装规范相关的政策时,应考虑护理环境。