Kostick Kristin, Trejo Meredith, Blumenthal-Barby J S
Baylor College of Medicine, Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy, Houston, TX 77030, USA.
J Clin Med. 2019 May 11;8(5):660. doi: 10.3390/jcm8050660.
Illness narratives with meaningful, competent and targeted content have been shown to provide useful guides for patient decision-making and have positive influences on health behaviors. The use of narratives in decision aids can confer a sense of structure, plot and context to illness experiences and help patients make treatment decisions that feel sensible, informed, and transparent.
This paper presents narratives of suffering and healing from patients and their caregivers with advanced heart failure who engaged in decision-making regarding Left Ventricular Device Assist (LVAD) treatment.
Narratives were collected from in-depth interviews with patients who accepted ( = 15) versus declined ( = 15) LVAD implant, LVAD candidates who had received education about LVAD and were in the process of making a decision ( = 15), and caregivers (family or significant others) of LVAD patients ( = 15).
Participants shared "restitution" narratives that most commonly conveyed a shift from pre-implant physical suffering and "daily hell," fatigue so intense it "hurts," along with emotional suffering from inability to engage with the world, to post-implant improvements in mobility and quality of life, including positivity and family support, adaptation on a "journey," "getting one's life back" and becoming "normal" again.
For LVAD patients, other patients' illness narratives can help to give meaning to their own illness and treatment experiences and to more accurately forecast treatment impacts on lifestyle and identity. For clinicians, patient narratives can enhance patient-practitioner communication and understanding by highlighting perspectives and values that structure patients' clinical experiences.
具有有意义、恰当且有针对性内容的疾病叙事已被证明可为患者决策提供有用指导,并对健康行为产生积极影响。在决策辅助工具中使用叙事可以赋予疾病经历一种结构、情节和背景感,并帮助患者做出感觉合理、明智且透明的治疗决策。
本文呈现了晚期心力衰竭患者及其照料者关于左心室装置辅助(LVAD)治疗决策的痛苦与康复叙事。
通过对接受LVAD植入的患者(n = 15)、拒绝LVAD植入的患者(n = 15)、已接受LVAD相关教育并正在做出决策的LVAD候选患者(n = 15)以及LVAD患者的照料者(家人或重要他人,n = 15)进行深入访谈来收集叙事。
参与者分享了“恢复”叙事,这些叙事最常传达了从植入前的身体痛苦和“日常地狱”(极度疲劳到“疼痛”,以及因无法融入世界而产生的情感痛苦)到植入后行动能力和生活质量的改善,包括积极心态和家庭支持、在“旅程”中的适应、“找回自己的生活”并再次变得“正常”。
对于LVAD患者而言,其他患者的疾病叙事有助于赋予他们自身疾病和治疗经历意义,并更准确地预测治疗对生活方式和身份认同的影响。对于临床医生来说(此处原文clinician有误,应为clinician),患者叙事可以通过突出构建患者临床经历的观点和价值观来加强医患沟通与理解。