Levine P A, Paling M R, Black W C, Cantrell R W
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 1987 Mar;96(3):260-7. doi: 10.1177/019459988709600306.
While magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is no longer a tool of the future, its availability is limited. Most hospitals still use high-resolution computed tomography (CT) scanning as their major imaging modality. Although numerous articles point to the improved diagnostic uses of MRI--as compared to high-resolution CT--a change from high-resolution CT scanning to MRI scanning throughout the United States would cost billions of dollars. We should, therefore, delineate those clinical situations in which magnetic resonance imaging is distinctly superior to high-resolution CT scanning. It is already an accepted fact that MRI provides improved imaging of the central nervous system, but, while recent articles maintain the superiority of MRI head and neck imaging, the advantages to the clinician are less clear. We present representative cases of large malignant tumors of the frontal, ethmoid, and sphenoid sinuses, in which the full extent of the disease which involved intracranial structures and the orbit was better defined on the MRI scan than it was on the high-resolution CT scan. Decisions concerning the involvement of the infratemporal fossa, the cavernous sinus, the optic chiasm, the pituitary, and the frontal lobes were more easily made when based upon magnetic resonance imaging, while the tumor involvement as evaluated by CT scanning was much less clear. Establishment of the problem regions of the head and neck--when magnetic resonance imaging is superior to high-resolution CT scanning--will assist in identification of the true need for this tool in the practice of the otolaryngologist--head and neck surgeon.
虽然磁共振成像(MRI)已不再是未来的工具,但其可用性有限。大多数医院仍将高分辨率计算机断层扫描(CT)作为主要的成像方式。尽管众多文章指出,与高分辨率CT相比,MRI在诊断方面有改进之处,但在美国,从高分辨率CT扫描转变为MRI扫描将耗资数十亿美元。因此,我们应该明确那些磁共振成像明显优于高分辨率CT扫描的临床情况。MRI能提供更好的中枢神经系统成像,这已是公认的事实,然而,尽管近期文章认为MRI在头颈部成像方面具有优势,但对临床医生来说,其优势并不那么明显。我们展示了额窦、筛窦和蝶窦大型恶性肿瘤的代表性病例,在这些病例中,MRI扫描比高分辨率CT扫描能更清晰地显示累及颅内结构和眼眶的疾病全貌。基于磁共振成像更容易判断颞下窝、海绵窦、视交叉、垂体和额叶是否受累,而CT扫描评估的肿瘤累及情况则不太清晰。明确头颈部中磁共振成像优于高分辨率CT扫描的问题区域,将有助于耳鼻喉科 - 头颈外科医生在实践中确定对该工具的真正需求。