Newman R J, Belch J, Kelly I G, Sturrock R D
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1987 May 30;294(6584):1392-3. doi: 10.1136/bmj.294.6584.1392.
The practice of holding combined orthopaedic and rheumatology clinics is widespread, but no attempt has been made to assess their usefulness. In a one year prospective study patients were randomised either to a combined clinic with a rheumatologist and an orthopaedic surgeon or to a clinic with an orthopaedic surgeon alone. The details of the patients' disease, the interview, the surgeons' and rheumatologists' responses, and the patients' opinions were recorded on questionnaires. Interviews were appreciably longer in the combined clinic, and more referrals for surgery were made. The rheumatologist correctly predicted the need for surgery in 95% of cases, and his presence in the clinic was considered desirable by the surgeon, principally when the referral letter was inadequate. It is concluded that most patients with rheumatic diseases can be seen more efficiently in routine orthopaedic clinics provided a good quality letter of referral is sent.
开设骨科与风湿病联合门诊的做法很普遍,但尚未有人尝试评估其效用。在一项为期一年的前瞻性研究中,患者被随机分为两组,一组前往有风湿病学家和骨科外科医生的联合门诊,另一组则只去看骨科外科医生。患者疾病详情、问诊情况、外科医生和风湿病学家的回复以及患者意见都记录在问卷上。联合门诊的问诊时间明显更长,且转介手术的情况更多。风湿病学家在95%的病例中正确预测了手术需求,外科医生认为他在门诊很有必要,主要是在转诊信内容不充分的时候。研究得出结论,只要能发出高质量的转诊信,大多数风湿病患者在常规骨科门诊就能得到更有效的诊治。