Markov Yuri A, Tiurina Natalia A, Utochkin Igor S
National Research University Higher School of Economics, Russia.
National Research University Higher School of Economics, Russia.
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2019 Jun;197:52-63. doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2019.05.003. Epub 2019 May 14.
The question of whether visual working memory (VWM) stores individual features or bound objects as basic units is actively debated. Evidence exists for both feature-based and object-based storages, as well as hierarchically organized representations maintaining both types of information at different levels. One argument for feature-based storage is that features belonging to different dimensions (e.g., color and orientations) can be stored without interference suggesting independent capacities for every dimension. Here, we studied whether the lack of cross-dimensional interference reflects genuinely independent feature storages or mediated by common objects. In three experiments, participants remembered and recalled the colors and orientations of sets of objects. We independently manipulated set sizes within each feature dimension (making colors and orientations either identical or differing across objects). Critically, we assigned to-be-remembered colors and orientations either to same spatially integrated or to different spatially separated objects. We found that the precision and recall probability within each dimension was not affected by set size manipulations in a different dimension when the features belonged to integrated objects. However, manipulations with color set sizes did affect orientation memory when the features were separated. We conclude therefore that different feature dimensions can be encoded and stored independently but the advantage of the independent storages are mediated at the object-based level. This conclusion is consistent with the idea of hierarchically organized VWM.
视觉工作记忆(VWM)是以单个特征还是以绑定的对象作为基本单元进行存储,这一问题目前仍存在激烈争论。基于特征的存储和基于对象的存储都有相应证据,同时也存在分层组织的表征,在不同层次上维护着这两种类型的信息。支持基于特征存储的一个论据是,属于不同维度的特征(如颜色和方向)可以在互不干扰的情况下存储,这表明每个维度都有独立的存储能力。在此,我们研究了跨维度干扰的缺失是反映了真正独立的特征存储,还是由共同对象介导的。在三个实验中,参与者记忆并回忆了多组对象的颜色和方向。我们在每个特征维度内独立操纵集合大小(使颜色和方向在不同对象间相同或不同)。关键在于,我们将需要记忆的颜色和方向分配给空间上整合在一起的同一组对象,或者分配给空间上分离的不同对象。我们发现,当特征属于整合在一起的对象时,每个维度内的精度和回忆概率不受不同维度集合大小操纵的影响。然而,当特征分离时,颜色集合大小的操纵确实会影响方向记忆。因此,我们得出结论,不同的特征维度可以独立编码和存储,但独立存储的优势是在基于对象的层面上介导的。这一结论与分层组织的VWM观点一致。