School of Medical Sciences, Bangor University, Wales, UK.
Manchester Royal Infirmary, Manchester, UK.
Resuscitation. 2019 Aug;141:1-12. doi: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2019.05.012. Epub 2019 May 23.
Clinically significant deterioration of patients admitted to general wards is a recognized complication of hospital care. Rapid Response Systems (RRS) aim to reduce the number of avoidable adverse events. The authors aimed to develop a core quality metric for the evaluation of RRS.
We conducted an international consensus process. Participants included patients, carers, clinicians, research scientists, and members of the International Society for Rapid Response Systems with representatives from Europe, Australia, Africa, Asia and the US. Scoping reviews of the literature identified potential metrics. We used a modified Delphi methodology to arrive at a list of candidate indicators that were reviewed for feasibility and applicability across a broad range of healthcare systems including low and middle-income countries. The writing group refined recommendations and further characterized measurement tools.
Consensus emerged that core outcomes for reporting for quality improvement should include ten metrics related to structure, process and outcome for RRS with outcomes following the domains of the quadruple aim. The conference recommended that hospitals should collect data on cardiac arrests and their potential predictability, timeliness of escalation, critical care interventions and presence of written treatment goals for patients remaining on general wards. Unit level reporting should include the presence of patient activated rapid response and metrics of organizational culture. We suggest two exploratory cost metrics to underpin urgently needed research in this area.
A consensus process was used to develop ten metrics for better understanding the course and care of deteriorating ward patients. Others are proposed for further development.
住院患者在普通病房中病情显著恶化是医院护理中公认的并发症。快速反应系统(RRS)旨在减少可避免的不良事件数量。作者旨在制定一个用于评估 RRS 的核心质量指标。
我们进行了一项国际共识过程。参与者包括患者、护理人员、临床医生、研究科学家以及来自欧洲、澳大利亚、非洲、亚洲和美国的国际快速反应系统学会的成员。文献的范围审查确定了潜在的指标。我们使用改良 Delphi 方法列出了候选指标清单,这些指标在广泛的医疗保健系统中进行了可行性和适用性审查,包括低收入和中等收入国家。写作小组对建议进行了完善,并进一步描述了测量工具。
达成共识认为,报告质量改进的核心结果应包括与 RRS 的结构、过程和结果相关的十个指标,其结果遵循四重目标的领域。会议建议医院应收集关于心脏骤停及其潜在可预测性、升级的及时性、重症监护干预措施以及普通病房患者书面治疗目标存在的数据。单位级别的报告应包括患者激活的快速反应和组织文化指标。我们建议使用两个探索性成本指标来支持该领域急需的研究。
使用共识过程制定了十个指标,以更好地了解恶化病房患者的病程和护理。还提出了其他指标以供进一步开发。