ENEA, National Institute of Ionizing Radiation Metrology, Rome, Italy.
Fisica Sanitaria, ASST Papa Giovanni XXIII, Bergamo, Italy.
Phys Med. 2019 May;61:94-102. doi: 10.1016/j.ejmp.2019.04.021. Epub 2019 May 3.
To assess the capability of different types of detectors to measure relative output factors (OF) at high dose per pulse by comparison with alanine dosimeters, which are independent of dose rate.
Measurements were made in 9 MeV and 7 MeV electron beams produced by a Novac7 accelerator for intraoperative radiotherapy. Applicators with diameter of 10-7-6-5 and 4 cm were used. The dose per pulse varied from about 30 mGy, for the 10 cm reference applicator, to about 70 mGy, for the 4 cm applicator. Five types of plane-parallel ionization chambers (PTW Advanced Markus, Markus and Roos, IBA PPC40 and PPC05), two types of silicon diodes (PTW 60017 and IBA EFD) and a PTW 60019 microDiamond were considered. For the ionization chambers, correction factors for ion recombination effects were determined for each applicator using a modified two-voltage-analysis method that includes the free-electron component.
Reference OF values were determined by alanine dosimeters with a standard combined uncertainty of 0.8%. Deviations from the reference OFs were generally within 1.5% for all the detectors, hence within the 95% confidence interval of alanine measurements. Larger deviations of up to about 2% obtained in a few cases are consistent with a 0.7% long-term reproducibility of OF measurements.
Comparison with alanine measurements demonstrated that all the detectors considered in this work can be used to measure OFs in high dose-per-pulse electron beams with an accuracy better than 2%, provided that appropriate corrections for ion recombination effects are applied when using ionization chambers.
通过与独立于剂量率的丙氨酸剂量计比较,评估不同类型探测器在高脉冲剂量下测量相对输出因子(OF)的能力。
在用于术中放射治疗的 Novac7 加速器产生的 9 MeV 和 7 MeV 电子束中进行了测量。使用直径为 10-7-6-5 和 4 cm 的施源器。每个脉冲的剂量从 10 cm 参考施源器的约 30 mGy 变化到 4 cm 施源器的约 70 mGy。考虑了五种平面平行电离室(PTW Advanced Markus、Markus 和 Roos、IBA PPC40 和 PPC05)、两种硅二极管(PTW 60017 和 IBA EFD)和一个 PTW 60019 微钻。对于电离室,使用包括自由电子分量的改进的双电压分析方法,为每个施源器确定了离子复合效应的校正因子。
使用标准不确定度为 0.8%的丙氨酸剂量计确定了参考 OF 值。对于所有探测器,与参考 OF 的偏差通常在 1.5%以内,因此在丙氨酸测量的 95%置信区间内。在少数情况下,测量得到的高达约 2%的较大偏差与 OF 测量的 0.7%长期重现性一致。
与丙氨酸测量的比较表明,在高脉冲剂量下测量 OF 时,只要在使用电离室时应用适当的离子复合效应校正,本工作中考虑的所有探测器都可以以优于 2%的精度使用。