Lucius Nick, Rose Kevin, Osborn Callin, Sweeney Matt E, Chesak Renel, Beslow Scott, Schenk Tom
City of Chicago, 333 S State St., Suite 420, Chicago, IL, 60604, USA.
Chi Hack Night, 2543 N Spaulding Ave, Suite 2, Chicago, IL, 60647, USA.
Water Res X. 2018 Dec 27;2:100016. doi: 10.1016/j.wroa.2018.100016. eCollection 2019 Feb 1.
Culture-based methods to measure () are used by beach administrators to inform whether bacteria levels represent an elevated risk to swimmers. Since results take up to 12 h, statistical models are used to forecast bacteria levels in lieu of test results; however they underestimate days with elevated fecal indicator bacteria levels. Quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR) tests return results within 3 h but are 2-5 times more expensive than culture-based methods. This paper presents a prediction model which uses limited deployments of qPCR tested sites with inter-beach correlation to predict when bacteria will exceed acceptable thresholds. The model can be used to inform management decisions on when to warn residents or close beaches due to exposure to the bacteria. Using data from Chicago collected between 2006 and 2016, the model proposed in this paper increased sensitivity from 3.4 percent to 11.2 percent-a 230 percent increase. We find that the correlation between beaches are substantial enough to provide higher levels of precision and sensitivity to predictive models. Thus, limited deployments of qPCR testing can be used to deliver better predictions for beach administrators at lower cost and less complexity.
海滩管理人员使用基于培养的方法来测量(),以判断细菌水平是否对游泳者构成更高风险。由于检测结果需要长达12小时才能得出,因此使用统计模型来预测细菌水平以替代检测结果;然而,它们低估了粪便指示菌水平升高的天数。定量聚合酶链反应(qPCR)检测可在3小时内返回结果,但成本比基于培养的方法高出2至5倍。本文提出了一种预测模型,该模型利用qPCR检测站点的有限部署以及海滩间的相关性来预测细菌何时会超过可接受阈值。该模型可用于为管理决策提供依据,以决定何时因接触细菌而警告居民或关闭海滩。利用2006年至2016年期间在芝加哥收集的数据,本文提出的模型将灵敏度从3.4%提高到了11.2%,提高了230%。我们发现,海滩之间的相关性足够大,可为预测模型提供更高的精度和灵敏度。因此,有限的qPCR检测部署可用于以更低的成本和更少的复杂性为海滩管理人员提供更好的预测。