School of Communication Sciences & Disorders, McGill University, Montréal, Quebec, Canada.
Centre for Research in Brain, Language and Music, Montréal, Quebec, Canada.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2019 Jul 15;62(7):2491-2500. doi: 10.1044/2019_JSLHR-L-18-0342. Epub 2019 Jun 13.
Purpose This study examined the utility of the Language ENvironment Analysis (LENA) recording system for investigating the language input to bilingual infants. Method Twenty-one French-English bilingual families with a 10-month-old infant participated in this study. Using the LENA recording system, each family contributed 3 full days of recordings within a 1-month period. A portion of these recordings (945 minutes) were manually transcribed, and the word counts from these transcriptions were compared against the LENA-generated adult word counts. Results Data analyses reveal that the LENA algorithms were reliable in counting words in both Canadian English and Canadian French, even when both languages are present in the same recording. While the LENA system tended to underestimate the amount of speech in the recordings, there was a strong correlation between the LENA-generated and human-transcribed adult word counts for each language. Importantly, this relationship holds when accounting for different-gendered and different-accented speech. Conclusions The LENA recording system is a reliable tool for estimating word counts, even for bilingual input. Special considerations and limitations for using the LENA recording system in a bilingual population are discussed. These results open up possibilities for investigating caregiver talk to bilingual infants in more detail.
目的 本研究旨在探讨语言环境分析(LENA)录音系统在研究双语婴儿语言输入方面的效用。 方法 21 个法裔英语双语家庭的 10 个月大的婴儿参与了这项研究。在 1 个月的时间内,每个家庭使用 LENA 录音系统提供 3 天完整的录音。这些录音中的一部分(945 分钟)被手动转录,并且将这些转录的单词数与 LENA 生成的成人单词数进行了比较。 结果 数据分析表明,即使在同一录音中同时存在两种语言,LENA 算法在计算加拿大英语和加拿大法语中的单词数时也是可靠的。虽然 LENA 系统往往低估了录音中的语音量,但对于每种语言,LENA 生成的和人工转录的成人单词数之间存在很强的相关性。重要的是,当考虑到不同性别和不同口音的语音时,这种关系仍然成立。 结论 LENA 录音系统是一种可靠的工具,可用于估计单词数,即使是双语输入。讨论了在双语人群中使用 LENA 录音系统的特殊考虑因素和限制。这些结果为更详细地研究照顾者与双语婴儿的对话开辟了可能性。