Paz Cortés Marta Macarena, Rojo Rosa, Mourelle Martínez María Rosa, Dieguez Pérez Montserrat, Prados-Frutos Juan Carlos
Department of Dental Clinical Specialties, School of Dentistry, Complutense University, Madrid 28040 Spain.
Department of Forensic and Legal Medicine, Faculty of Health Sciences, Rey Juan Carlos University, Alcorcón 28922, Spain.
Forensic Sci Int. 2019 Aug;301:318-325. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2019.05.057. Epub 2019 Jun 7.
The aim of this study was to estimate the age of subjects from their dental age by showing the different stages of tooth development using the Nolla method in a Spanish population sample considering the gender, age group, and the development of the two dental arches. The sample consisted of 604 orthopantomographs corresponding to Spanish children (male: 302 and female: 302) aged from 4 to 14 years old. The resulting chronological and dental ages were compared using Student's t-test. We obtained a good index of agreement between the evaluators and good internal consistency in the evaluation of the ages of the teeth. In general, the dental age estimates were lower than the chronological ages, obtaining an underestimation with the application of the Nolla method. In the male group, the average dental age of the maxillary teeth was 8.36 years and that of the mandibular teeth was 8.40 years, compared to the chronological age of 8.84 years in both cases. In the female group, the average dental age of the maxillary teeth was 7.76 years and that of the mandibular teeth was 7.88 years, compared to the chronological age of 8.70 years in both cases. On applying the Nolla method to our sample, a significant overestimation was observed only in children aged between 4 and 6.9 years. The Nolla method can be used as a complementary tool for estimating age in children of Spanish origin. The application of this method is more favourable in the case of individuals evaluated under the law applied to minors. In general, with this method, age is underestimated, but the calculations involved are reliable, and greater precision has been observed in male than in female. The data from this study can be used as a reference to determine the dental maturity of Spanish children and to estimate their ages.
本研究的目的是通过使用诺拉方法展示牙齿发育的不同阶段,在一个西班牙人群样本中,考虑性别、年龄组以及两个牙弓的发育情况,从受试者的牙齿年龄来估计其实际年龄。样本包括604张西班牙儿童(男性302名,女性302名)的口腔全景片,年龄在4至14岁之间。使用学生t检验比较得出的实际年龄和牙齿年龄。我们在评估者之间获得了良好的一致性指标,并且在牙齿年龄评估中具有良好的内部一致性。总体而言,牙齿年龄估计低于实际年龄,应用诺拉方法会出现低估情况。在男性组中,上颌牙齿的平均牙齿年龄为8.36岁,下颌牙齿为8.40岁,而两者的实际年龄均为8.84岁。在女性组中,上颌牙齿的平均牙齿年龄为7.76岁,下颌牙齿为7.88岁,而两者的实际年龄均为8.70岁。将诺拉方法应用于我们的样本时,仅在4至6.9岁的儿童中观察到显著高估。诺拉方法可作为估计西班牙裔儿童年龄的补充工具。在适用于未成年人的法律下对个体进行评估时,这种方法的应用更有利。一般来说,用这种方法年龄会被低估,但所涉及的计算是可靠的,并且观察到男性比女性的精度更高。本研究的数据可作为确定西班牙儿童牙齿成熟度和估计其年龄的参考。