Stolarski Allan E, Kim Na Eun, O'Neal Patrick, Sanchez Vivian, Whang Edward, Kristo Gentian
Department of Surgery, Boston Medical Center, Boston University Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts; Department of Surgery, Veterans Affairs Boston Healthcare System, Boston, Massachusetts.
Department of Surgery, Boston Medical Center, Boston University Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts; Department of Surgery, Veterans Affairs Boston Healthcare System, Boston, Massachusetts.
J Surg Educ. 2019 Nov-Dec;76(6):1622-1628. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2019.05.005. Epub 2019 Jun 22.
With the fragmented rotational structure of training, exposure to surgical staplers is not uniform across surgical residents. Traditionally, educational sessions dedicated to instruction in surgical staplers have taken place outside the operating room. This study implemented and evaluated an intraoperative timeout immediately prior to stapler use in cases with surgical residents.
During general surgery cases from June 1, 2017 until December 31, 2017, surgical teams, including the surgical attending, surgical resident, and scrub nurse participated in an intraoperative instructional timeout, during which proper use of linear or circular staplers was reviewed. At the conclusion of the timeout, residents were required to demonstrate proper stapler assembly and verbalize all technical steps involved in stapler use. Duration of each timeout was recorded. Immediately following the case, a pre-post survey was administered to each participating junior (R1-R2) or senior (R4-R5) surgical resident. The primary outcome was change in stapler use knowledge by surgical residents. Survey questions with Likert scale responses were analyzed using paired ttests, and responses from junior residents were compared to those from senior residents with independent t tests.
Forty-three general surgery cases involved stapler use during the study period and implemented an intraoperative instructional timeout. The educational intervention increased stapler use knowledge significantly in all surgical residents. Prior to the timeout, junior residents reported significantly higher anxiety related to stapler usage compared to their senior counterparts; anxiety scores in junior residents decreased significantly for use of both linear and circular staplers. The mean timeout duration was 2.9 minutes (standard deviation 0.9 minutes, range 1.2-4.6 minutes). All participating surgical residents recommended routine implementation of an instructional timeout prior to intraoperative stapler use.
An intraoperative timeout dedicated to stapler teaching is effective in increasing proficiency and easing anxiety in all levels of surgical residents. Further research is warranted to determine whether this educational intervention would translate into fewer stapler use errors and decreased intraoperative complications.
由于培训的旋转结构分散,外科住院医师接触外科吻合器的机会并不均等。传统上,专门针对外科吻合器使用指导的教育课程是在手术室之外进行的。本研究在有外科住院医师参与的手术病例中,于使用吻合器前立即实施并评估了术中暂停。
在2017年6月1日至2017年12月31日的普通外科手术病例中,手术团队,包括主刀医生、外科住院医师和洗手护士参与了术中指导性暂停,期间回顾了直线型或圆形吻合器的正确使用方法。在暂停结束时,住院医师需要演示吻合器的正确组装,并说出吻合器使用过程中涉及的所有技术步骤。记录每次暂停的持续时间。病例结束后,立即对每位参与的初级(R1 - R2)或高级(R4 - R5)外科住院医师进行术前术后调查。主要结果是外科住院医师在吻合器使用知识方面的变化。使用配对t检验分析具有李克特量表回答的调查问题,并使用独立t检验比较初级住院医师和高级住院医师的回答。
在研究期间,43例普通外科手术病例使用了吻合器并实施了术中指导性暂停。教育干预显著提高了所有外科住院医师的吻合器使用知识。在暂停之前,初级住院医师报告与高级住院医师相比,与吻合器使用相关的焦虑程度显著更高;初级住院医师在使用直线型和圆形吻合器时的焦虑评分均显著降低。平均暂停持续时间为2.9分钟(标准差0.9分钟,范围1.2 - 4.6分钟)。所有参与的外科住院医师都建议在术中使用吻合器前常规实施指导性暂停。
专门用于吻合器教学的术中暂停有效地提高了各级外科住院医师的熟练程度并缓解了焦虑。有必要进行进一步研究以确定这种教育干预是否会转化为更少的吻合器使用错误和减少术中并发症。