Chan Bun
Graduate School of Engineering , Nagasaki University , Bunkyo 1-14 , Nagasaki 852-8521 , Japan.
J Phys Chem A. 2019 Jul 11;123(27):5781-5788. doi: 10.1021/acs.jpca.9b03976. Epub 2019 Jun 26.
We have obtained benchmark data for a set of small molecular systems of Cu, Ag, and Au using coupled-cluster methods. Using this collection of reference data (that we termed the CUAGAU set) for assessing DFT-type methods, we find the MN15-L nonhybrid DFT to be cost-effective for geometry optimization [mean absolute deviation (MAD) in bond length = 0.20 Å], with an accuracy that is comparable to that for the double-hybrid (DH) DFT method DSD-PBEP86 (MAD = 0.19 Å). For the computation of thermochemical properties, among "conventional" (non-MP2-based) DFT methods, the best performance is found for the global-hybrid meta-GGA functional MN15, with an MAD of 11.4 kJ mol. We also find the nonhybrid method B97M-rV to have a reasonable performance (MAD = 14.4 kJ mol), and it may serve as a cost-effective means for qualitative study. If we look beyond conventional functionals, we find DSD-PBEP86 (MAD = 7.3 kJ mol) to be more accurate than even MN15. Nonetheless, this level of accuracy is still not sufficient for quantitative studies. In this regard, high-level wave function methods such as composite procedures that are based on coupled cluster are still indispensable for obtaining reliable reference data for transition-metal species.
我们使用耦合簇方法获得了一组铜、银和金的小分子体系的基准数据。利用这组参考数据(我们称之为CUAGAU集)来评估密度泛函理论(DFT)类型的方法,我们发现MN15-L非杂化DFT在几何优化方面具有成本效益[键长的平均绝对偏差(MAD)=0.20 Å],其精度与双杂化(DH)DFT方法DSD-PBEP86(MAD = 0.19 Å)相当。对于热化学性质的计算,在“传统”(非基于MP2)的DFT方法中,全局杂化元广义梯度近似(meta-GGA)泛函MN15表现最佳,MAD为11.4 kJ/mol。我们还发现非杂化方法B97M-rV具有合理的性能(MAD = 14.4 kJ/mol),它可作为定性研究的一种经济有效的手段。如果我们超越传统泛函,会发现DSD-PBEP86(MAD = 7.3 kJ/mol)甚至比MN15更准确。然而,这种精度水平对于定量研究仍然不够。在这方面,诸如基于耦合簇的复合程序等高阶波函数方法对于获得过渡金属物种可靠的参考数据仍然是不可或缺的。